Thursday, 29 August 2013

NUMERACY ACROSS ALL LEARNING AREAS

Numerate behavior can be thought of as the disposition and competence to use mathematics in the service of endeavors other than mathematics. Numeracy is linked to ‘what mathematics you know’, but it also involves the skills, thinking processes and attitudes needed to choose and use mathematics outside mathematics. In this sense, numeracy is about practical knowledge that has its origins and importance in the physical or social world rather than in the conceptual field of mathematics itself.


The major responsibility for developing students’ numeracy lies with the Mathematics learning area. At all levels, teachers of mathematics should help students learn to use their mathematics to solve practical problems and as a tool for learning beyond the mathematics classroom. Teachers of mathematics should also take responsibility for teaching students to read and write in situations that involve mathematical ideas, notations and visual forms.

However, the development of numeracy involves more than mathematics classrooms alone can provide, since its achievement requires working mathematically in a range of different settings. Indeed, school mathematics is unable to fully capture all that is numeracy simply because the mathematics is in mathematics. In order for them to be ‘numerate’, students must learn to connect the mathematics from situation to situation
– including across the school curriculum and beyond. Learning areas other than mathematics can, therefore, contribute to the enhancement of students’ numeracy by:
• providing rich contexts in which students can use their mathematics;
• expecting students to use their mathematics in other learning areas; and
• maintaining common and challenging standards. 


In The Arts learning Area, for example, students might consider what shapes they and others find pleasing. In doing so they are likely to use and also to enrich the language of shape and number developed in mathematics. Mathematics lessons might build upon this work on form, using the golden ratio as a starting point for considering ratios in general. Mathematics lessons could also involve students in trying to find out whether people actually do prefer particular shapes and forms, thus developing important ideas about data collection and handling and about the value and applicability of their mathematical work.


The Society and Environment and the Health and Physical Education learning areas may each call upon and enrich number, measurement and data skills when students investigate such matters as water wastage or rubbish generation and disposal in the school yard, their own fitness levels or adolescent health. The Society and Environment and Mathematics learning areas may also provide complementary work which develops an understanding of how three-dimensional space can be represented in two dimensions – as in various map projections – but never without some distortion, so that interpreting a two-dimensional representation requires an understanding of the features of the three-dimensional space that are and are not preserved in the two-dimensional representation.


The Technology and Enterprise learning area will also both draw upon and enhance students’ understanding of the representation of three-dimensional space in two dimensions. Indeed, the design and production of models involved in achieving the outcomes of Technology and Enterprise will draw extensively upon number,
measurement and space concepts and skills, and should also considerably enhance students’ learning in these areas by providing a broader range of contexts and experiences than could be provided in mathematics alone.


The Science, Society and Environment and Mathematics learning areas each contribute to students’ understanding of how time may be represented sequentially or in a linear fashion and of how the tracking and measurement of time relates to cyclical or periodic phenomena. These learning areas, together with the Languages Other than English learning area, can help students to understand that people may conceive of time differently and in culturally-specific ways. Thus, students can come to understand that the application of particular mathematical ideas to the measurement and recording of time is both influenced by and influences how we think about and experience time in our daily lives and in our myths and legends. The English learning area provides the language foundations essential for the learning of mathematics and the development of numeracy. Equally, developing students’ capacities to draw on a wide range of mathematical ideas in their reading and viewing generally is a major contribution of numeracy to English. English and mathematics together provide the basic information skills involved in reading the daily newspaper or a telephone book, and in preparing reports.
Thus, within each learning area, two questions should be asked:
• How can the learning area enhance students’ numeracy?
• How can numeracy contribute to enhanced outcomes in the learning area?
Answering these two question will require teachers to collaborate in developing common interpretations of numeracy and strategies to assist their students to use mathematics across and beyond the school curriculum.

LINKS TO THE OUTCOMES IN THE OVERARCHING STATEMENT - MATHS LEARNING

Mathematics is integral in the education of young people. The Mathematics learning area, either directly or indirectly, contributes to each of the Overarching outcomes. In addition, through numeracy, it provides learning skills which contribute the achievement of the outcomes for most of the learning areas of the curriculum.

Students’ achievement of the outcomes in Working Mathematically, Number, Measurement, Chance and Data, Space, and Algebra will enable them to deal with quantitative and spatial ideas; to collect, display, analyse and interpret data; and to describe and reason about patterns and relationships. Thus, the Mathematics learning area takes a major – although certainly not sole – responsibility for ensuring that
students: 
• select, integrate and apply numerical and spatial concepts and techniques;
• recognise when and what information is needed, locate and obtain it from a range of sources and evaluate, use and share it with others; and
• describe and reason about patterns, structures and relationships in order to understand, interpret, justify and make predictions.


The Mathematics learning area supports and reinforces the literacy work of the school by setting expectations and providing feedback and support to students that is consistent with current thinking in literacy. It also takes a major responsibility for assisting students to learn to read, write, listen to and talk about mathematics, and to develop the range of special symbols, vocabulary and diagrammatic representations that mathematics contributes to language. In these ways, the Mathematics learning area makes a direct contribution to enabling students to: 
• use language to understand, develop and convey ideas and information and interact with others.


Mathematics plays a central role in the generation of technology generally and has, itself, changed significantly as a result of the impact of computing technologies. Through the achievement of a number of the Mathematics learning area outcomes, students:
• select, use and adapt technologies.


Through the Mathematics learning area, students come to appreciate the way in which mathematics is embedded in the very fabric of our own and other societies. Their understanding of the cultural and intellectual significance of mathematical activity, and how it influences what we are and might be, enhances the extent to which they:
• understand their cultural, geographic and historical contexts and have the knowledge, skills and values necessary for active participation ;
• interact with people and cultures other than their own and are equipped to contribute to the global community; and
• participate in creative activity of their own and understand and engage with the artistic, cultural and intellectual work of others.

The outcomes in Appreciating Mathematics and Working Mathematically address the mathematical attitudes, appreciations, and individual and collaborative work habits that enable students to be critical, creative and confident users of mathematics. With the provision of a supportive environment for learning mathematics, appropriate mathematical challenge and teaching processes that foster autonomous learning in mathematics, this means that students:
• visualise consequences, think laterally, recognise opportunity and potential and are prepared to test options;
• are self-motivated and confident in their approach to learning and are able to work individually and collaboratively; and
• recognise that each person has the right to feel valued and be safe and, in this regard, understand their rights and obligations and behave responsibly.

Finally, the Mathematics learning area makes an indirect contribution to several Overarching outcomes – and hence to other learning areas – as a result of its responsibilities for numeracy. Numeracy generally benefits learning in most parts of the school curriculum, while being innumerate can inhibit and even prevent student
learning elsewhere. In particular, being numerate can significantly enhance students’ capacity to:
• understand and appreciate the physical, biological and technological world and have the knowledge and skills to make decisions in relation to it;
• understand their cultural, geographic and historical contexts and have the knowledge, skills and values necessary for active participation ;
• value and implement practices that promote personal growth and well-being; and
• participate in creative activity of their own and understand and engage with the artistic, cultural and intellectual work of others.


Issues in the design of technology-supported learning environments utilizing cognitive conflict

The design and use of learning environments utilizing cognitive conflict to promote learning necessarily involve consideration of three processes: concept representation, conflict recognition and conflict resolution. Of these, the process most critical for design is, concept representation. The effectiveness of the learning environment in facilitating the learner's recognition and resolution of cognitive conflict depends largely on effective concept representation in the environment.


In the confrontational approach the 'correct' or target structure must be represented in the environment. Typically in this approach the designer will make assumptions about the cognitive structures likely to be brought to the situation by learners but will not attempt to represent these directly in the environment. The guiding approach requires that the designer have a good appreciation of the conceptual structures likely to be brought to the situation by learners, as this approach requires the planning of experiences that will help learners to build on their existing conceptual structures to develop more 'appropriate' ones. Explicit representation of these structures in the environment may not be necessary. However if the developmental sequence is to be effective, the designer must apprehend not only learners' initial conceptual structures but also changes to these that are likely to result from experiences within the environment.


From the point of view of design, the explanatory approach is perhaps the most subtle of the three described. In comparison with the previous approaches, this one requires the designer to have a clear understanding of the conceptual structures of the learner and, further, a reasonable idea of the learner's underlying rationale for these structures. In the ball toss example, the designer is confident that learners can make correct predictions about the motion based on their current conceptual structures, but he anticipates that these structures contain weaknesses that are revealed only when reasons or explanations for the
predictions are investigated.


Through increasing the options for concept representation, the use of technology has enhanced considerably the potential for design and development of learning environments utilizing cognitive conflict. An exhaustive discussion of the possibilities here is beyond the scope of the present paper. However it is appropriate to mention the ability of these environments to provide multiple formalisms for representation of concepts for students, including linguistic, graphical, animated, mathematical, programming code and many other representational modes.


For effective utilization of cognitive conflict in a learning environment, the designer must ensure that the consequences of the differences between 'target' and learner conceptual structures are evident and understandable by the learner. For learners, apprehension and articulation of a puzzling or unexpected situation is a major step towards resolving it. In environments designed with the confrontational approach the conflict is generally immediate and very obvious. In the guided approach where the designer expects gradual,
probably small changes in .the learners' cognitive structures, the recognition of conflict may not be as striking.
Using the explanatory approach the designer must take great care to ensure that the recognition of conflict with previously held understandings in fact actually happens. This might mean directing the learner's attention quite deliberately to the aspects of the environment designed for this, perhaps through suggested activities to be undertaken in the environment or by some other suitable design strategy.



Some aspects of technology-supported learning environments can be used to enhance the processes of conflict recognition and resolution. For example, interactivity in well designed technology-based learning environments can provide feedback to learners about the appropriateness of their assumptions and predictions as they work in the environment, and technology might be used to sponsor collaboration to help conflict resolution.


The processes of concept representation, conflict recognition and conflict resolution are discussed, and the most important of these from a design perspective, concept representation, is examined in some detail in the context of the three approaches. Finally to considers the power of technology-supported learning environments to enable, particularly through increased options for concept representation, the design and development of learning environments that utilize cognitive conflict in the more complex and subtle ways described in the three approaches delineated in the article.Although much of the recent work on cognitive conflict has been undertaken in education, the argument presented in the article should not be confined to learning of particular subject area . Papert points out that 'Piaget has shown that children hold false theories as a necessary part of the process of learning to think' (Papert, 1980: 132-3). It is contended that the argument made here has application learning in a wide variety of subject areas and contexts.

Cognitive conflict and learning

Piaget used the term disequilibration to describe the process of an individual's encountering a new experience that generates a contradiction with the individual's existing cognitive structures (see for example Piaget, 1977), and argued that cognitive development or learning occurs as the individual attempts to resolve this cognitive conflict, a process he referred to as accommodation. He proposed three possible types of accommodation: the individual might ignore the contradiction; the individual might hold two theories simultaneously, dealing with the contradiction by applying one theory in some specific cases, and the other in others; or the individual might construct a new, more encompassing notion that explains and resolves the prior contradiction. Achieving this last type of accommodation, that is learning, is the purpose of teaching and of educational software design in the present context.


Some other writers, a leader among whom is Seymour Papert, regard the issue of cognitive conflict with a somewhat different emphasis from that in the body of work just described. Papert considers cognitive conflict to be part of the vital process of theory building in learning. He assigns rather less importance to the efficient achievement of 'correct' concepts, valuing the unorthodox theories and explanations developed by learners. He emphasizes the importance for learning of this process of building and modification of theories.
Papert argues that the unorthodox theories of young children are not deficiencies or cognitive gaps, but that they serve as a way of flexing cognitive muscles, or developing and working through the necessary skills needed for more orthodox theorizing. He asserts that educators distort Piaget's message by seeing his contribution as revealing that children hold false beliefs, which they, the educators, must overcome (Papert, 1980). This leads to the development of learning environments that use cognitive conflict somewhat less directly than implied by the science education work outlined earlier. It suggests the creation of open-ended learning environments in which students might explore concepts and ideas, developing (possibly 'wrong' or transitional) theories and testing these. Papert uses the word microworlds to describe such learning environments.


Microworlds (Papert, 1980; Squires and McDougall, 1986) are self-contained environments, simple restricted worlds 'in which certain questions are relevant and others are not' (Papert, 1980: 117). Learners explore the properties of a chosen microworld in a completely open-ended fashion, developing and testing theories about the environment as they do so. Papert advocates the construction of many such microworlds, each with its own set of assumptions and constraints; a microworld designer can lead a learner to new understandings by careful control of these assumptions and constraints. In later work (see for example Harel and Papert, 1991; Harel, 1991) Papert and his colleagues advocate the construction by learners of microworlds of their own; however, this paper is concerned only with the development for teaching purposes of environments designed specifically to promote cognitive conflict in learners.


Andrea diSessa, who worked for some years with Papert, assigns even greater importance to learners' pre-existing cognitive structures. He discusses these in terms of intuitive knowledge, referring to the many fragmentary small structures that a learner gleans from experience in the world as phenomenological primitives or p-prims (diSessa, 2000). DiSessa describes cognitive conflict in the following way. People have hundreds if not thousands of p-prims, and when they make a judgement of reasonableness or unreasonableness they are frequently summoning all the relevant p-prims and deciding which one, or which collection of a few, best matches the situation. Then what happens in the situation is reasonable if it matches the chosen p-prim or p-prims and surprising if it does not. Like Papert, diSessa is critical of what he sees as educators' under-valuing of learners' intuitive knowledge, arguing that learners are adjusting their p-prims to new experiences all the time and that it is not difficult to make small changes of this kind.



Problem based learning method/model

In the problem based learning model the students’ turn from passive listeners of information receivers to active, free self-learner and problem solvers. It also shifts the emphasis of educational programs from teaching to learning. It enables the students to learn new knowledge by facing the problems to be solved instead of feeling boredom. Problem based learning affect positively certain other attributes such as problem solving, information acquisition, and information sharing with others, group works, and communication etc. Again problems solving is a deliberate and serious act, involves the use of some novel method, higher thinking and systematic planned steps for the acquisition set goals. The basic and foremost aim of this learning model is acquisition of such information which based on facts (Yuzhi, 2003 & Mangle, 2008).


According to Gallagher et. al,(1999) in problem based learning environment, students act as professionals and are confronted with problems that require clearly defining and well structured problems, developing hypothesis, assessing, analyzing, utilizing data from different sources, revising initial hypothesis as the data collected developing and justifying solutions based on evidence and reasoning. The practice of problem based learning is richly diverse as educators around the world and in a wide range of disciplined have discovered it as a route to innovating education, The educators used problem solving method as an educational tool to enhance learning as a relevant and practical experience, to have students’ problem solving skills and to promote students’ independent learning skill. Eng (2001) opined problem based learning as a philosophy aims to design and deliver a total learning environment that is holistic to student-centered and student empowerment.


Presenting the students with a problem, give them opportunity to take risks, to adopt new understandings, to apply knowledge, to work in context and to enjoy the thrill of being discoverers. Tick, (2007) stated that in the student-centered learning environment that is desirable for problem based learning, the central figure of the learning-teaching process is the student. The learning objective is not the reproduction, recall and learning of passively received learning material but the active and creative engagement of students in group work and in individual study thus transferring the skills and knowledge. The individual, autonomous self-directed learning gives the freedom to the learner to decide individually and consciously on the learning strategy and on the time scale, s/he wants to follow.


The most important achievement of a teacher is to help his/her students along the road to independent learning. In problem based learning, teacher acts just as facilitator, rather than a primary source of information or dispenser of knowledge. Roh, (2003) argued that within problem based learning environments, teachers' instructional abilities are more critical than in the traditional teacher-centered classrooms. Beyond presenting mathematical knowledge to the students, teachers in problem based learning environments must engage students in marshaling information and using their knowledge in applied sand real settings. Evidence of poor performance in mathematics by elementary school students highlight the facts that the most desired technological, scientific and business application for mathematics cannot be sustained. This makes it paramount to seek for a strategy for teaching mathematics that aims at improving its understanding and performance by students practically (Okigbo & Osuafor, 2008). Problem solving as a method of teaching may be used to accomplish the instructional roles of learning basic facts, concepts, and procedure, as well as goals for problem solving. Problem solving is a major part of Mathematics has many applications and often those applications represent important problems in, mathematics. We include problem solving in school mathematics because it can stimulate the interest and enthusiasm of the students (Wilson, 1993).


Wednesday, 28 August 2013

PROBLEM-BASED LEARNING AND MATHEMATICS

Starting from the assumption that problem-based learning is an instructional approach suitable for transmitting
a real understanding of mathematics, we have to regret that such a methodology is not common in real teaching practice at school, as teachers usually rely on self perpetuating “traditional” methods. These  include:
• training courses for pre-service and in-service teachers;
• organizing problem-based mathematical laboratories in school (both in primary school and at a higher level);
• designing interactive exhibitions;
• organizing web-based mathematical game contests;
• publishing books and magazines.
It is my believe that the role of Research is crucial in carrying on synergical actions both on the teachers and on the pupils in order to improve the effectiveness of the teaching of mathematics.


Problem-based learning (PBL) is a constructivist learner-centred instructional approach based on the analysis, resolution and discussion of a given problem. It can be applied to any subject, indeed it is especially useful for the teaching of mathematics . For a neat definition of PBL we refer to according to which PBL “is an instructional (and curricular) learner-centered approach that empowers learners to conduct research, integrate theory and practice, and apply knowledge and skills to develop a viable solution to a defined problem”. Typically a PBL session follows these steps :
• pupils are given a problem;
• they discuss the problem and/or work on the problem in small groups, collecting information useful to solve the problem;
• all the pupils gather together to compare findings and/or discuss conclusions; new problems could arise from this discussion, in this case
• pupils go back to work on the new problems, and the cycle starts again.

In spite of researches documenting the effectiveness of PBL, we have to regret that such a methodology is not common in real teaching practice at school, as teachers usually rely on self perpetuating “traditional” methods . Research should thus focus on finding ways to support teachers practice in schools.


When designing refresher courses for teachers, it is important to focus not only on disciplinary contents, but also on methodological aspects. That is, on one side one has to deal with the peculiar nature of mathematics, keeping in mind that ordinary people usually have a conflicting relation with mathematics. This bad attitudes is often due to wrong beliefs about the subject, which is seen as a dull set of rules to be learned by heart. Thus teachers should give their students the opportunity to see mathematics as a living subject, that is as an exploratory, dynamic, and evolving science. Teachers should teach their students that the short answer is not what they really need, and that things must be looked at in depth. And this is the place where methodology steps in: simply put, if mathematics is an exploratory subject, then it must be taught in an exploratory way. The socio-constructivist perspective enforce this point of view, and doing mathematics in a PBL learner centred environment is a chance to give students a real understanding of the subject. Once again, the basic idea is that you do not appreciate and learn mathematics if you do not do mathematics.

Moreover, once accepted that PBL is an effective way to teach mathematics, one has to act on teachers’ beliefs in order to have them actually use PBL in their teaching practice. According to my experience, the most effective way to have teacher willing to use a PBL methodology is to have they experience themselves the joy of mathematical discovery, hence the courses for in-service teachers now adopt PBL. By undergoing PBL, teachers acquire beliefs in favour of  a PBL methodology as they see that in this way they learn some good maths . The main criticism concerns the fact that PBL is time consuming, and it is thus important to show teachers that the time is well spent as pupils get a real understanding of the subject, and gain at the same time many collateral competencies . A further objection coming from the teacher is that such activities rely on “good” problems and in-service teachers do not feel to be competent enough to create suitable ones. Researchers can provide teachers with ready to use material. There is one more aspects that needs to be stressed in order to use PBL teachers must be trained as their role is crucial. Once more the personal experience is the best ground on which they can build an effective teaching practice.


Basics of Set Theory - A breif perspective

When you start reading this, the first thing you should be asking yourselves is “What is Set Theory and why is it relevant?” Though Propositional Logic will prove a useful tool to describe certain aspects of meaning, like the reasoning in (1), it is a blunt instrument.
(1) a. Jacques sang and danced
Therefore: Jacques sang
b. If Jacques kisses Smurfette, she will slap Jacques
   Jacques kissed Smurfette
Therefore: Smurfette slaps Jacques
Propositional Logic won’t help us with the argument in (2), which is why we will extend it to Predicate Logic.
(2) Every man is mortal
     Aristotle is a man
Therefore: Aristotle is mortal.

Our intuitions tell us that if the first and second sentence are true, then the third necessarily follows. The reasoning goes like this. Suppose the first sentence is true: the collection of men is part of the collection of mortal things. Now suppose the second sentence is also true: Aristotle is a man. The first sentence says that if a thing is in the collection of men, it is also in the collection of mortal things. So it follows that Aristotle is a mortal thing (or simply mortal), which is what the third sentence states.  The semantics of Predicate Logic is defined in terms of Set Theory.


A bunch of carrots, a classroom full of students, a herd of elephants: these are all examples of sets of things. Intuitively, you can think of a set as an abstract collection of objects, which may correspond to things in the world or to concepts, etc. A set is sometimes also called a collection.1 The objects that are collected in a set
are called its members or elements. So, a carrot, a student, and an elephant, are members of the sets described above. A Set may also contain other sets as its members.

I offer no definition of what a set is beyond the intuitive notion described above. Instead, I am going to show you what can be done with sets. This is a typical approach to Set Theory, i.e., sets are treated as primitive s of the theory and are not definable in more basic terms. I adopt the notation in (4) for convenience.

(4) a. Capital letters represent sets: A, B, C, …
     b. Lower case letters represent members of sets: a, b, c, …, sometimes x, y, z, … The principal concept of Set Theory is belonging, i.e., elements belonging to sets. And this concept is represented using the membership relation, expressed by the rounded Greek letter epsilon ∈, as in (5). It’s negation is expressed using a barred epsilon ∉ as in (6).

(5) x ∈ A
x is an element of the set A.

(6) x ∉ A
x is not an element of the set A.


Elements
The objects in sets are called elements (or members).
If an element e belongs to set S this is represented as e∈S.
If an element f does not belong to set S this is represented as f∉S.

Writing sets
1. Listing method
All of the elements of a set are written.
A = {1, 3, 5, 7, 9}
2. Set - builder method
A typical element is named, along with its description, such as:
B = {x | x is an odd number from 1 to 10}
The vertical bar | is read: ‘‘such that’’, and it also can be written as :
3. Venn diagram
A Venn diagram is used for graphical representation of the set as a collection of its objects.
Example 1
This is a typical set, consisted of numbers 1, 2 and 3 listed inside of braces:
{1, 2, 3}
Alternatively we may choose to describe this set like this
{1, 2, 3} = { integers greater than 0 and less than 4 }
More formally, we may use this notation:
{1, 2, 3} = { x : x is an integer and 0 < x < 4} = { x : x  Z, 0 < x < 4 }


Singleton set
Singleton set is a set with only one element.
A singleton set is different from the element itself and it is denoted by the element with surrounding braces.
Ex. 5 – this is number 5
{5} –this is singleton set containing number 5

Empty Set
A set with no elements in it is called an empty set.
This set is unique and it is denoted with the symbol Ø or with empty braces { }.

Infinite set
Set which contain an infinite number of elements is called infinite set.
These sets are often given by a few elements and ellipses which indicate that this sequence continues indefinitely.
A = {1, 2, 3, … }
Subsets
If all the elements of one set X are also elements of another set Y, then X is said to be a subset of Y. Similarly  if elements of Z are not elements of another set Y so it is not a subset of Y.

Superset
If a set X is a subset of Y, then Y is said to be a superset of X. Every set is its own subset and superset. The empty set is a subset of all sets.
Example 2
Let A = {1, 2, 3} and B = {1, 2}.
B is a subset of A.
A is not a subset of B then  notice that: n (B) < n (A).

SET OPERATIONS
Example: Let A = {10, 11, 12, 13} and B = {12, 13, 14}.

Intersection
Symbol A ∩ B denotes the intersection of two sets.
It is a set comprised of the elements which are in the both sets. We can write this as:
A ∩ B = { x| x∈  A and x ∈ B }
In the example A ∩ B = {12, 13}
If two sets have no elements in common, i.e. A ∩B = Ø we say that they are disjoint.

Union
Symbol A U B denotes the union of two sets.
It is a set comprised of the elements which are in the either set (at least one). We write this as:
A U B = { x : x ∈ A or x ∈ B }
In the example A U B = {10, 11, 12, 13, 14}

Universal set
The set containing all elements of a problem is called the universal set (ℰ).
That is a set from which elements may be considered.
(The notation comes from the French word ensemble).

Complement
If ℰ is universal set and A is a subset of ℰ, then the complement of a set A, denoted by A’, is the
set of all elements not in A.
A’ = { x : x ∉ A }

Cardinality of sets (Number of elements)
The number of elements in a set A is called its cardinality and is denoted by n (A)
Example. If A = {a, b, c, d, e, f} then n (A) = 6.
Properties of Cardinality:
1. n(Ø) = 0
2. n(A’) = n(ℰ) – n(A)
3. if A ∩ B ≠ Ø then
n(AUB) = n(A) + n(B) – n(A ∩ B)
4. if A ∩ B = Ø (disjoint sets) then
n(AUB) = n(A) + n(B)


Set-theoretic equalities
There are a number of general laws about sets which follow from the definitions of settheoretic
operations, subsets, etc. A useful selection of these is shown below. They are
grouped under their traditional names. These equations below hold for any sets X, Y, Z:
1. Idempotent Laws
(a) X ∪ X = X (b) X ∩ X = X
2. Commutative Laws
(a) X ∪ Y = Y ∪ X (b) X ∩ Y = Y ∩ X
3. Associative Laws
(a) (X ∪ Y) ∪ Z = X ∪ (Y ∪ Z) (b) (X ∩ Y) ∩Z = X ∩ (Y ∩ Z)
4. Distributive Laws
(a) X ∪ (Y ∩ Z) = (X ∪ Y) ∩ (X ∪ Z) (b) X ∩ (Y ∪ Z) = (X ∩ Y) ∪ (X ∩ Z)
5. Identity Laws
(a) X ∪ ∅ = X (c) X ∩ ∅ = ∅
(b) X ∪ U = U (d) X ∩ U = X
6. Complement Laws
(a) X ∪ X’ = U (c) X ∩ X’ = ∅
(b) (X’)’ = X (d) X – Y = X ∩ Y’
7. DeMorgan’s Laws
(a) (X ∪ Y)’ = X’ ∩ Y’ (b) (X ∩ Y)’ = X’ ∪ Y’
8. Consistency Principle
(a) X ⊆ Y iff X ∪ Y = Y (b) X ⊆ Y iff X ∩ Y = X