Saturday, 31 August 2013

The Modularity of the Human Mind

A basic assumption regarding the three modalities described in this chapter is that experiences can and frequently are encoded in memory using all three modalities. That is, experiences are stored or encoded as three dimensional "packets." This modularity assumption is quite consistent with current brain theory. Anderson (1995) refers to these modular encoding of experience as "records." The concept that the brain has a modular structure has received a great deal of attention over the last two decades. Gazzaniga (1985) describes the modularity of the brain in the following way:

By modularity, I mean that the brain is organized into relatively independent functioning units that work in parallel. The mind is not an indivisible whole operating in a single way to solve all problems . . . the vast and rich information impinging on our brain is broken into parts . . . (p. 4) In his book The Modular Brain (1994), Richard Restak details the historical development of the concept of brain modularity, noting that over time it replaced the theory that the brain has a strict hierarchic organization. Restak credits Johns Hopkins neuroscientist  Vernon Mountcastle as the primary architect of the modern modular theory. He cites Mountcastle as saying:
. . . Most people don’t think hierarchically anymore; they shy away from saying "This function resides here." Instead, we now believe the brain is arranged according to a distributed system composed of large numbers of modular elements linked together. That means the information flow through such a system may follow a number of different pathways, and the dominance of one path or another is a dynamic and changing property of the system. (Restak, 1994, p. 35) 

The discussion of modularity by Restak, Mountcastle, and Gazzaniga addresses the physical architecture of the brain. Here I refer to the psychological structure of the mind & the structure of stored experience. As discussed previously, a basic assumption of the theory presented in this book is that human experiences are stored in three dimensional modules. For example, if a person goes to a football game, the experience will be encoded as mental pictures, smells, tastes, sounds, and kinesthetic sensations & all forms of non linguistic representation. The individual might also store emotions associated with the game such as anger or joy & forms of the affective modality. Finally, the individual will encode the experience as deep-structure propositions describing what occurred & forms of the linguistic modality. Some psychologists believe that, over time, the linguistic modality becomes the dominant mode of processing. "The behaviors that these separate systems emit are monitored by the one system we come to use more and more, namely the verbal natural language system" (Gazzaniga and LeDoux, 1978, p. 150). The primacy of language was demonstrated in a study by Mandler and Ritchey (1977). Subjects were shown ten pictures, one right after another. Pictures contained fairly common scenes like a teacher at a blackboard with a student working at a desk. After viewing eight such pictures for ten seconds each, subjects were presented with a series of pictures and asked to identify which ones they had seen. The series contained the exact pictures they had studied as well as distraction pictures. Two types of distractors were used, token distractors and semantic changes. Token distractor pictures changed details of the target pictures like the pattern in the teacher’s dress. Pictures that contained semantic changes altered some element that was at a high level of importance in terms of the propositional network representing the picture. For example, a semantic change might change the teacher from a male to a female. There was no systematic difference in the amount of physical change in the pictures between token changes and semantic changes. Subjects recognized the original pictures 77 percent of the time, rejected the token distractors only 60 percent of the time, but rejected the semantic distractors 94 percent of the time. In short, subjects had encoded each picture as a linguistically-based set of abstract propositions with an accompanying visual representation. It was the propositional changes in the picture that were best recognized, not the changes in the nonlinguistic aspects of the information.


Conversely, arguments are also made that the emotional system is the primary representational modality. Specifically, a good case can be made for the assertion that the affective modality exerts the most influence over human thought and experience. This case is well articulated in LeDoux’s The Emotional Brain: The Mysterious Underpinnings of Emotional Life (1996). Among other things, as a result of his analysis of the research on emotions, LeDoux concludes that human beings 1) have little direct control over their emotional reactions, and 2) once emotions occur, they become powerful motivators of future behavior. Relative to humans’ lack of control over emotions LeDoux notes:
Anyone who has tried to fake an emotion, or who has been the recipient of a faked one, knows all too well the futility of the attempt. While conscious control over emotions is weak, emotions can flood consciousness. This is so because the wiring of the brain at this point in our evolutionary history is such that connections from the emotional systems to the cognitive systems are stronger than connections from the cognitive systems to the emotional systems. (p. 19)

Relative to the power of emotions once they occur, Le Doux explains:
They chart the course of moment-to-moment action as well as set the sails toward long-term achievements. But our emotions can also get us into trouble. When fear becomes anxiety, desire gives way to greed, or annoyance turns to anger, anger to hatred, friendship to envy, love to obsession, or pleasure to addiction, our emotions start working against us. Mental health is maintained by emotional hygiene, and mental problems, to a large extent, reflect a breakdown of emotional order. Emotions can have both useful and pathological consequences. (pp. 19-20) For LeDoux, then, emotions are primary motivators that often outstrip an individual’s system of values and beliefs relative to their influence on human behavior. This was demonstrated in a study by Nisbett and Wilson (1977) who found that people are often mistaken about internal causes of their actions and feelings. The researchers noted that individuals always provide reasons for their actions. However, when reasoned and plausible reasons are not available, people make up reasons and believe them. As described by LeDoux, this illustrates that the forces that drive human behavior cannot be attributed to the rational conclusions generated by our linguistic mind, but are functions of the inner workings of our emotional mind.

Learning Progressions - Curriculum, Instruction and Assessment Design

One of the major challenges to bringing mathematics, as well as most emerging science, into the classroom is their interdisciplinary nature.  However, students often have difficulty making connections between different scientific concepts and ideas. For instance, students often have difficulty applying knowledge from one part of the particulate model of matter to another (Renström, Andersson, & Marton,1990). In addition, students often use models of different levels to describe different concepts related to the structure and behavior of matter. (Harrison & Treagust, 2000).


The integration of knowledge is made more difficult by typical large-scale and classroom assessments ostensibly based on the standards. Such assessments commonly focus on targeted, isolated topics that do not require students to connect currently taught concepts with concepts from other science areas that were previously learned (NRC, 2005; Pellegrino, Chudowsky, & Glaser, 2001). Instead, these assessments encourage teachers to focus on isolated bodies of knowledge that ultimately results in compartmentalized application of science concepts. As a result, the traditional curriculum often compartmentalizes the various aspects of the study of matter (e.g. structure of matter, conservation of matter, chemical reactions, phase changes). The authors of documents such as Benchmarks for Science Literacy (AAAS, 1993) and the National Science Education Standards (NRC, 1996) suggested connections between key concepts among multiple disciplines in the sciences. However, these connections have not been borne out in most science curricula nor are they a part of typical assessment practices. Thus, in order to generate literacy in emerging sciences, school curricula must begin to emphasize not only the learning of individual topics, but also the connections between them and assessments must be developed to support such a curriculum.


This study describes work towards developing and validating the sequence and assumptions behind a learning progression. The processes of assessment that we use might ultimately be translated into both classroom and large-scale assessment strategies/materials. In addition, the work informs both the curricular structure and instruction by providing insight into how students connect ideas from other science disciplines with a core scientific concept. Thus, this approach might provide a method for identifying the connections that are required to obtain a deep conceptual understanding of an interdisciplinary field such as nano science. A learning progression describes what it means to move towards more expert understanding in an area and gauges students’ increased competence related to a core concept or a scientific practice (Smith et al., 2004). They consist of a sequence of successively more complex ways of thinking about an idea that might reasonably follow one another in the process of students developing understanding about that idea. However, as we address interdisciplinary subject matter, we can no longer consider learning progressions in a linear fashion. Rather, learning progressions may be viewed as strategic sequencing that promotes both branching out and forming connections between ideas related to a core scientific concept. We can better assess students’ conceptual understanding by designing items that assess the connections between
related science topics and ideas.


In order to provide a conceptual explanation of most nano scale phenomena, a deep and thorough understanding about the nature of matter is required. This includes the structure and properties of matter and how it behaves under a variety of conditions. To make progress on how students’ understanding about the nature of matter develops, we need to construct a learning progression.  However, this progression is only theoretical as it is does not represent the curriculum that is followed in the classroom nor do we have much empirical evidence to support this progression. Therefore, although the suggested progression is consistent with national standards, it requires collection of empirical evidence to verify a possible learning progression that can be applied to describe the learning of our target populations. This study is directed towards assessing and characterizing how and when students make the connections between the ideas as they progress towards a deep conceptual understanding. It affords practical guideline to develop test items for measuring students’ learning progression. As we study student learning of the nature of matter, we explore these questions:
1. How do students’ ideas about concepts regarding the nature of matter develop over time?
2. How can we assess the requisite connections between concepts that traditionally have been compartmentalized in instruction?


In this article I try to present how we can develop and validate a potential learning progression to use for the development of assessing student learning in nano science, specifically in the topic areas involving the structure, properties and behavior of matter. Our work is a case study that illustrates the design of assessments based on a learning progression through research and development cycles. Our principles include (a) elaborating standards and Benchmarks to create a hypothetical learning progression, (b) collecting various data to validate the learning progression, (c) revising the learning progression based on the collected data, and (d) developing items for assessing student’s placement on the learning progression. The difficulties that we have identified in students’ conceptual understanding of the nature of matter are not necessarily because the material is developmentally inappropriate. As more learning progressions are developed and validated, they can be used to guide teaching and curriculum development. If students were presented with an exemplary curriculum that helped to foster their understanding and facilitate the connections they must make between ideas to have a deep understanding of a science topic, the problems we observed might not occur.

The SOLO Taxonomy

The SOLO Taxonomy is based on the study of outcomes of academic teaching. SOLO is short for “Structure of the Observed Learning Outcome” and the taxonomy names and distinguishes five different levels according to the cognitive processes required to obtain them: “SOLO describes a hierarchy where each partial construction [level] becomes a foundation on which further learning is built” (Biggs, 2003, p. 41). SOLO can be used to define ILOs, forms of teaching that support them, and forms of assessment that evaluate to what extent the ILOs were achieved. It is developed aiming at research-based university teaching as the research activities behind it ultimately converge on real research (i.e. on the production of new knowledge) at its fifth and highest level. The five levels are as follows, in increasing order of structural complexity (Biggs & Collis, 1982, pp. 17-31; Biggs, 2003, pp. 34-53; Biggs & Tang, 2007, pp. 76-80):


SOLO 1: “The Pre-Structural Level”
Here the student does not have any kind of understanding but uses irrelevant information and/or misses the point altogether. Scattered pieces of information may have been acquired, but they are unorganized, unstructured, and essentially void of actual content or relation to a topic or problem.

SOLO 2: “The Uni-Structural Level”
The student can deal with one single aspect and make obvious connections. The student can use terminology, recite (remember things), perform simple instructions/algorithms, paraphrase, identify, name, count, etc.

SOLO 3: “The Multi-Structural Level”
At this level the student can deal with several aspects but these are considered independently and not in connection. Metaphorically speaking; the student sees the many trees, but not the forest. He is able to enumerate, describe, classify, combine, apply methods, structure, execute procedures, etc.

SOLO 4: “The Relational Level”
At level four, the student may understand relations between several aspects and how they might fit together to form a whole. The understanding forms a structure and now he does see how the many trees form a forest. A student may thus have the competence to compare, relate, analyze, apply theory, explain in terms of cause and effect, etc.

SOLO 5: “The Extended Abstract Level”
At this level, which is the highest, a student may generalize structure beyond what was given, may perceive structure from many different perspectives, and transfer ideas to new areas. He may have the competence to generalize, hypothesize, criticize, theorize, etc. We define competence progression as moving up the SOLO levels; i.e. SOLO-progression. Surface learning (which has similarities to instrumental understanding) implies that the student is confined to action at the lower SOLO levels (2-3); whereas deep learning (which has similarities to relational understanding) implies that the student can act at any SOLO level (2-5), including the higher levels (4-5). As we move up the SOLO hierarchy, we first see quantitative improvements as the student becomes able to deal with first a single aspect (from 1-2) and then more aspects (from 2-3). Later we see qualitative improvements (from 3-4) as the details integrate to form a structure; and (from 4- 5) as the structure is generalized and the student can deal with information that was not given. For these reasons, the levels 2 and 3 are sometimes referred to as quantitative levels; levels 4 and 5 as the qualitative.



Taxonomies for understanding - “ What is understanding”

The purpose of  teaching is inter alia that students should learn something; i.e., they should attain some level of understanding and skills. However, the term ‘understanding’ is used for many different things such as one student’s capacity to name main concepts involved in topic X and another student’s critical comparison of practical implications of theoretic models of topic X. These two uses of ‘understanding’ are different and embody both surface and deep understanding, respectively. According to Wittgenstein, words get their meaning from their use: “Nur in der Praxis einer Sprache kann ein Wort Bedeutung haben” (Wittgenstein, 1991, p. 344), but the usage of ‘understanding’ is ambiguous, hence its meaning is not clear. In Sausurre’s (1997, pp. 12-13) terminology, one could say that the term ‘understanding’ is a double entity constituted by one distinct succession of syllables (syllables), but multiple meanings (signification) linked to the syllables. Some clarity is therefore needed when one for instance explains the kind of understanding of topic X that is intended by the teacher and that will be tested at an examination. Skemp (1987, pp. 152-163) defined two types of understanding. ‘Instrumental understanding’ is “rules without reasons” for instance that you ‘understand’ that to divide a fraction by a fraction “you turn it upside down and multiply”. ‘Relational understanding’ occurs when one has built up a conceptual structure (schema) of topic X and therefore both know what to do and why when one solves a problem within that topic. However, Skemp’s distinction does not formulate a gradual development or levels of understanding.


 There are several taxonomies describing various levels of understanding. Gall (1970) presented an overview of eight of these of which Bloom’s is probably the most well known. These have been developed inter alia to classify questions “based on the type of cognitive process required to answer the question” (Gall, 1970, p. 708). Gall furthermore stated: “I have organised the categories to show similarities between the systems. It appears that Bloom’s Taxonomy best represents the commonalities that exist among the systems” (Gall, 1970, p. 710). Lewis (2007) gave a rather similar overview of five taxonomies. 

These taxonomies have been further developed but the basic ideas are still the same and particularly Bloom’s Taxonomy is still very widely used. However, they were not developed specifically with university teaching in mind and furthermore Bloom did not make his taxonomy with the purpose of formulating ILOs but to be able to select representative tasks for an examination (Biggs & Collis, 1982, p. 13). Below we therefore present a taxonomy for understanding “understanding” particularly aimed at assessing university students’ competencies. Following the discussion from above, this taxonomy distinguishes between “learn (to do)” and “learn about”. Lists of “learn about” are content statements using nouns listing the concepts and areas of knowledge that the students will encounter during the course. But this is not the same as what they “learn (to do)”. Curricula writers need to ask themselves what they want the students to get out of meeting these areas of knowledge; i.e., what do they want the students to learn to do? When assessing a student, we cannot actually measure the student’s knowledge “inside the brain”. What we can do, however, is to have a student do something, and then measure the product and/or the process. Therefore, it is important to focus on what the student does and on what the students are supposed to “learn (to do)”, i.e. what competencies the students are expected to have by the end of the course. As generally advocated in Outcomes-Based Education (OBE); in particular, in Constructive Alignment (Biggs, 2003), we therefore focused on having course descriptions with ILOs formulated using verbs stating what the students should be able to do by the end of the course. Having these things made explicit furthermore makes it easier to explain to the students what they are supposed to get out of a course.


Learning progressions

By its very nature, learning involves progression. To assist in its emergence, teachers need to understand the pathways along which students are expected to progress. These pathways or progressions ground both instruction and assessment. Yet, despite a plethora of standards and curricula, many teachers are unclear about how learning progresses in specific domains. This is an undesirable situation for teaching and learning, and one that particularly affects teachers’ ability to engage in formative assessment.


The purpose of formative assessment is to provide feedback to teachers and students during the course of learning about the gap between students’ current and desired performance so that action can be taken to close the gap. To do this effectively, teachers need to have in mind a continuum of how learning develops in any particular knowledge domain so that they are able to locate students’ current learning status and decide on pedagogical action to move students’ learning forward. Learning progressions that clearly articulate a progression of learning in a domain can provide the big picture of what is to be learned, support instructional planning, and act as a touchstone for formative assessment.


Learning progressions define the pathway along which students are expected to progress in a domain. They identify the enabling knowledge and skills students‘ need to reach the learning goal as well as provide a map of future learning opportunities. Heritage, Kim, Vendlinski, and Herman (2009) explain that learning progressions are important to the development of progressive sophistication in skills within a domain. One view of learning progressions suggests that they are presented to students as a continuum of learning, accounting for different rates of learning (DeMeester & Jones, 2009). The rate of individual student‘s progress may vary along the learning progressions, but progressions should ultimately connect the knowledge, concepts, and skills students develop as they evolve from novice to more expert performances (Heritage, 2008). In this way, teachers and students should be able to ―see and understand the scaffolding they will be climbing as they approach‖ (Stiggins, 2005, p. 327) learning goals. In addition, if learning is derailed at any point, a teacher can identify this and adjust accordingly.

It is fair to say that if the standards do not present clear descriptions of how students learning progresses in a domain, then they are unlikely to be useful for formative assessment. Standards are insufficiently clear about how learning develops for teachers to be able to map formative assessment opportunities to them. This means that teachers are not able determine where student learning lies on a continuum, and know what to do to close the gap between current learning and desired goals. Explicit learning progressions can provide the clarity that teachers need. By describing a pathway of learning they can assist teachers to plan instruction. Formative assessment can be tied to learning goals and the evidence elicited can determine students’ understanding and skill at a given point. When teachers understand the continuum of learning in a domain and have information about current status relative to learning goals (rather than to the activity they have designed to help students meet the goal), they are better able to make decisions about what the next steps in learning should be.


This progression of learning allows teachers to position their students' learning, not only in relation to their current class(es) and the objectives for that cohort, but also in relation to prior and subsequent classes. Consequently, teachers are able to view current learning against a bigger picture of development. In terms of instruction, they are able to make connections between prior and successive learning. Also, information from formative assessment can be used to pinpoint where students’ learning lies on the continuum. Sometimes this will mean that teachers have to move backwards along the continuum, for example, if key building blocks are missing. Similarly, they might move learning further forward if some students are outpacing their peers. In both cases, the continuum allows them to make an appropriate match between instruction and the learners' needs.

Assessment for learning - Formative Assessment

Assessment for learning was originally conceived of as formative assessment and placed in contrast to summative assessment. Michael Scriven proposed the terms formative and summative in 1967 to explain two distinct roles that evaluation could play in evaluating curriculum. In the years to follow, Benjamin Bloom and colleagues (1969; 1971) suggested applying the same distinction to the evaluation of student learning— ―what we tend today to call assessment‖ (Wiliam, 2006, p. 283). Subsequently, the terms formative and summative have become fundamental to understanding assessment in education. Summative assessment focuses on summing up or summarizing achievement of students, classes, schools, etc. (Bloom, Hastings, & Madus, 1971; National Research Council [NRC], 2001; Sadler, 1989; Shavelson, 2006). Formative assessment centers on active feedback loops that assist learning (Black & Wiliam, 2004; Sadler, 1989; Shavelson, 2006). Recently, some scholars have begun to refer to summative assessment as assessment of learning and formative assessment as assessment for learning (Black & Wiliam, 2003; Broadfoot, 2008; Gipps & Stobart, 1997; Stiggins, 2002).


In the years since Scriven‘s identification and Bloom‘s extension of summative and formative assessment types, ―the interest (and investment) in summative assessment has far outstripped that accorded to formative assessment‖ (Stiggins, 2005, p. 326). Black and Wiliam (2003) discuss in some detail the ups and downs of formative assessment during the 1970s through the late 1980s. In the late 1980s, two substantial review articles (Crooks, 1988; Natriello, 1987) and a seminal piece on the function of formative assessment in the development of expertise (Sadler, 1989) boosted interest in assessment for learning. This growing interest appeared to be substantiated with Fuchs and Fuchs‘ (1986) meta-analysis and Black and Wiliam‘s (1998) comprehensive review of about 250 articles. Both studies reported significantly positive student learning gains. The Black and Wiliam (1998) work demonstrated gains of a half to a full standard deviation, with low-achieving students making the largest increase. Although Dunn and Mulvenon (2009) have recently contested the conclusiveness of these two studies,1 other recent research has also shown positive impact on student learning (e.g., Black, Harrison, Lee, Marshall, & Wiliam, 2004; Ruiz- Primo & Furtak, 2006). Moreover, Dunn and Mulvenon (2009) were unable to present any examples of formative assessment producing negative achievement results.


In addition to the consensus emerging around the potential benefits of formative assessment practice, scholars generally agree that formative assessment is the process of using information about students‘ learning on the course of instruction to make decisions to improve learning (Atkin, Black, & Coffey, 2001; Bell & Cowie, 2001; Black, 1993; Black, Harrison, Lee, Marshall, & Wiliam, 2003; Black & Wiliam, 1998, 2004; Harlen, Gipps, Broadfoot, & Nuttall, 1992; Harlen & James, 1996; Tunstall & Gipps, 1996; Shepard, 2000).


How the process of formative assessment is conceptualized and implemented still varies somewhat, but all of the researchers listed above agree that regular testing and simply informing students of their scores does not constitute formative assessment. Instead, according to Black and associates (2004), the evidence of student understanding (and learning) evoked from one round of the formative assessment process should be ―used to adapt the teaching work to meet learning needs‖ (p. 2). In 2007, Formative Assessment for Students and Teachers State Collaborative (FAST SCASS) of the Council of Chief State Officers with national and international researchers in formative assessment identified five attributes of the formative assessment process from the literature. They are as follows:
 Learning progressions should clearly articulate the sub-goals of the ultimate learning goal.
 Learning goals and criteria for success should be clearly identified and communicated to students.
 Students should be provided with evidence-based feedback that is linked to the intended instructional outcomes and criteria for success.
 Both self- and peer-assessment are important for providing students an opportunity to think metacognitively about their learning.
 A classroom culture in which teachers and students are partners in learning should be established. Margaret Heritage (2007) of the National Center for Research on Evaluation, Standards, and Student Testing (CRESST) folded the attributes into a model of the formative assessment process that is applicable . The process focuses the work on the following four elements of formative assessment: learning progressions, including learning goals and success criteria, identifying the gap, eliciting evidence of learning, teacher assessment, teacher feedback, and student involvement.

Thursday, 29 August 2013

COGNITIVE TRAITS - Reasoning Ability

With respect to reasoning abilities, we can distinguish between inductive, deductive and abductive reasoning. In the following discussion, we will focus on inductive reasoning, since this ability is the most important one regarding learning. We shall also provide some discussion on deductive reasoning. Inductive reasoning skills relate to the ability to construct concepts from examples. When a student faces a complicated problem, he/she looks for known patterns, and uses them to construct a temporary internal hypotheses or schema in which to work (Bower & Hilgard, 1981). It is easier for students who possess better inductive reasoning skill to recognize a previously known pattern and generalize higher-order rules. As a result, the load on working memory is reduced, and the learning process is more efficient. In other words, the higher the inductive reasoning ability, the easier it is to build up the mental model of the information learned. According to Harverty, Koedinger, Klahr, & Alibali (2000) inductive reasoning ability is the best predictor for academic performance. For simulation based discovery learning, students are asked to infer characteristics of a model through experimentations by using a computer simulation and thus are asked to use their inductive reasoning skills. According to Veermans and van Joolingen (1998) simulation based discovery learning results in deeper rooting of  the knowledge, enhanced transfer, the acquisition of regulatory skills, and would yield better motivation. However, discovery learning does not always yield to better learning results. One of the reasons is that students have difficulties in performing the required processes. To improve the learning progress and support learners with low inductive reasoning abilities, Veermans and van Joolingen have designed a mechanism that provides advices based on the performed experiments in the simulation. This mechanism is integrated in SimQuest, an authoring system for simulation based discovery (van Joolingen & de Jong, 2003).



Considering again exploratory learning and the Exploration Space Control elements, for learners with low inductive reasoning skills, many opportunities for observation should be provided. Therefore, learning systems can support these learners by providing a high amount of well-structured and concrete information
with many paths. For learners with high inductive reasoning skills, the amount of information and paths should decrease to reduce the complexity of the hyperspace and hence enable the learners to grasp the concepts quicker. Moreover, information can be presented in a more abstract way (Kinshuk & Lin, 2003). Deduction is defined as drawing logical consequences from premises. An application for deductive reasoning is, for instance, naturalistic decision making (Zsambok & Klein, 1997), which deals with examining what people do in real world situations. It has been observed that experienced decision makers recognize the situation and associate an appropriate solution whereas unexperienced decision makers perform an unorganized and almost random search of alternatives. When it comes to complex situations, humans often fail in finding appropriate solutions. According to Dörner (1997) several reasons exist for such failures, for example, humans tend to oversimplify the mental model of the complex system, tend to be slow in thinking when it comes to conscious thoughts, or tend to ignore the possibility of side-effects. However, Dörner’s experiments showed that leaders from business and industry tend to make more effective decisions in complex situations. Therefore, he argued that the necessary behavior and skills can be acquired and learnt.