Wednesday, 4 September 2013

Interpreting multiple representations

“The good thing about this was, instead of like working out of your textbook, you had to use your brain before you could go anywhere else with it. You had to actually sit down and think about it. And when you did think about it you had someone else to help you along if you couldn't figure it out for yourself, so if they understood it and you didn't they would help you out with it. If you were doing it out of a textbook you wouldn't get that help.”


Mathematical concepts have many representations; words, diagrams, algebraic symbols, tables, graphs and so on. These activities are intended to allow these representations to be shared, interpreted, compared and grouped in ways that allow learners to construct meanings and links between the underlying concepts. In most mathematics teaching and learning, a great deal of time is already spent on the technical skills needed to construct and manipulate representations. These include, for example, adding numbers, drawing graphs and manipulating formulae. While technical skills are necessary and important, this diet of practice must be balanced with activities that offer learners opportunities to reflect on their meaning. These activities provide this balance. Learners focus on interpreting rather than producing representations. Perhaps the most basic and familiar activities in this category are those that require learners to match pairs of mathematical objects if
they have an equivalent meaning. This may be done using domino-like activities. More complex activities may involve matching three or more representations of the same object. 


Typical examples might involve matching:

1. times and measures expressed in various forms (e.g. 24-hour clock times and 12-hour clock times);
2. number operations (e.g. notations for division – see below);
3. numbers and diagrams (e.g. decimals, fractions, number lines, areas);
4.algebraic expressions (e.g. words, symbols, area diagrams – see below);
5.statistical diagrams (e.g. frequency tables, cumulative frequency curves). 


The discussion of misconceptions is also encouraged if carefully designed distractors are also included. The examples below show some possible sets of cards for matching. They show how learners’ attention can be focused on the way notation is interpreted, and common difficulties may be revealed for discussion. 


The activities offer learners a number of mathematical statements or generalizations. Learners are asked to decide whether the statements are ‘always’, ‘sometimes’ or ‘never’ true, and give explanations for their decisions. Explanations usually involve generating examples and counterexamples to support or refute the statements. In addition, learners may be invited to add conditions or otherwise revise the statements so they become ‘always true’. This type of activity develops learners’ capacity to explain, convince and prove. The statements themselves can be couched in ways that force learners to confront common difficulties and misconceptions. Statements might be devised at any level of difficulty. They might concern, for example:

1. the size of numbers (“numbers with more digits are greater in value”);
2. number operations (“multiplying makes numbers bigger”);
3.area and perimeter (“shapes with larger areas have larger perimeters”);
4.algebraic generalisations (“2(n + 3) = 2n + 3”);
5.enlargement (“if you double the lengths of the sides, you double the area”);
6. sequences (“if the sequence of terms tends to zero, the series converges”);
7. calculus (“continuous graphs are differentiable”); . . . and so on.


Throughout this process, the teacher’s role is to:
1.encourage learners to think more deeply, by suggesting that they try further examples (“Is this one still true for decimals or negative numbers?”; “What about when I take a bite out of a sandwich?”; “How does that change the perimeter and area?”);

2. challenge learners to provide more convincing reasons (“I can see a flaw in that argument”; “What happens when . . . ?”); ! play ‘devil’s advocate’ (“I think this is true because . . .”; “Can you convince me I am wrong?”).



Instructional Implications of Intrinsic Cognitive Load

Inappropriate instructional designs can impose a heavy extraneous cognitive load that interferes with learning.
In addition, it was suggested in the previous section, that element interactivity also imposes a cognitive load. If cognitive load is caused by a combination of design features and element interactivity, then the extent to which it is important to design construction to reduce extraneous cognitive load, may be determined by the level of element interactivity. While extraneous cognitive load can severely reduce instructional effectiveness, it may do so only when coupled with a high intrinsic cognitive load. If the total cognitive load is not excessive due to a relatively low intrinsic cognitive load, then a high extraneous cognitive load may be irrelevant because students are readily able to handle low element interactivity material with almost any form of presentation. In contrast, if intrinsic cognitive load is high because of high element interactivity, adding a high extraneous cognitive load may result in a total load that substantially exceeds cognitive resources, leading to learning failure.


Because of the predilections of the investigators, the goal-free, worked example, split attention and redundancy effects (discussed above) were all tested using high element interactivity materials with a high intrinsic cognitive load. Associating such materials with high extraneous cognitive load presentation modes may result in overwhelming high cognitive loads. As a consequence, it is to be expected that reducing extraneous cognitive by the various techniques associated with each effect results in substantial performance increments. Nevertheless, the advantages found may be available only with high element interactivity materials. All the effects may disappear using low element interactivity materials because total cognitive load levels may not exceed available capacity. Consider the spot-attention effect. Sweller et al. (1990) demonstrated this effect teaching students numerical control programming. This language requires students,
among other things, to learn how to move an object using a co-ordinate system with a very high level of element interactivity. In common with other co-ordinate systems, it is difficult, if not impossible, to learn how the system works without learning the entire system. To move an object from one position to another, one must learn, for example, that a diagonal movement can be represented by simultaneous movements on both the X and Y axes, in addition to learning the codes for moving on these two axes. Basically, proficiency can be obtained only by learning how each of the elements of the coordinate system interact. Simply learning one element such as moving up the X-axis will not provide an essential understanding of the system. All elements and their relations must be learned. Sweller et al. (1990) found that integrating diagrams of the coordinate system with explanatory text was far superior to the conventional split-source format of diagrams and separate text.


In contrast to numerical control programming, consider another computer application such as learning to use a word processor. This application may be taught by separately explaining the meaning of each command and diagrammatically demonstrating its screen output and/or consequences or by integrating the explanation with the output and consequences to eliminate split-attention. In this case, eliminating split-attention may have no positive consequences. This result would not follow because word processor procedures involve less information or less time to learn than numerical control programming. Indeed, it may take longer to learn how to use a word processor than to learn elementary aspects of numerical control programming. The word processing task appears easier because each element is relatively independent of other elements and can be learned readily without reference to other elements. Learning how to insert text can be learned quite independently of learning how to delete text or how to move the cursor about the screen or how to format a document for printing. Each command can be learned in isolation with minimal interaction between them. As a consequence, intrinsic cognitive load is low and integrating command meaning with diagrams of its screen consequences may have minimal effects on learning efficiency. Sweller and Chandler (1994) found that the split-attention effect could be obtained when learning a numerical control programming language but not when learning word-processing procedures. Similar arguments apply to the other effects generated by cognitive load theory. The redundancy effect is not likely to occur if we are dealing with low element interactivity materials and a low intrinsic cognitive load. If each redundant segment of material can easily and readily be assimilated, its inclusion may not have negative consequences. Again, Sweller and Chandler (1994) obtained the redundancy effect using numerical control programming but not word processing.


As other examples, both the goal-free and worked example effects occur because goal free problems and worked examples are compared to solving conventional problems by means-ends analysis. A means-ends strategy invariably involves high element interactivity because it requires problem solvers to simultaneously consider the goal, the current problem state, differences between them, problem solving operators and relations between these various entities. (Relations between element interactivity and means-ends analysis were pointed out to me by Paul Chandler.) If problem solving strategies other than means-ends analysis with reduced element interactivity are employed, the goal-free and worked example effects may not occur. Comparing worked examples with a problem solving strategy that does not require the problem solver to simultaneously process several elements is not likely to result in a worked example advantage. Indeed, goal-free problem solving is just such a strategy. Compared to a means-ends strategy, a goal-free strategy requires problem solvers to process only a very limited number of elements at any given time. To solve a goal-free problem one merely needs to consider a problem state and any operator that can be used at that point (see Sweller, 1988). It is reasonable to assume that any problem solving strategy used by subjects that reduces element interactivity compared to means-ends analysis should reduce cognitive load and reduce or eliminate the goal-free or worked example effects. (It needs to be recognized that when we are discussing problem solving strategies, normally we are concerned with extraneous rather than intrinsic cognitive load because the load can be altered by altering the strategy used by students. If a change in strategy affects cognitive load then we are dealing with extraneous rather than intrinsic cognitive load.)


In summary, the instructional consequences of extraneous cognitive load may be heavily determined by intrinsic cognitive load caused by element interactivity. An extraneous cognitive load may have minimal consequences when dealing with material that has low element interactivity because the total cognitive load may be relatively low. The effects of extraneous cognitive load may manifest themselves primarily when dealing with high element interactivity materials because the combined consequences of a high extraneous and high intrinsic cognitive load may overwhelm limited processing capacity. Thus, we should not expect to demonstrate those effects reliant on cognitive load using low element interactivity materials.


Learning mechanisms: schema acquisition

A schema is a cognitive construct that organizes the elements of information according to the manner with which they will be dealt. An early discussion of schemas was presented by Bartlett (1932). He demonstrated that what is remembered is only partly dependent on the information itself. Newly presented information is altered so that it is congruent with knowledge of the subject matter. Knowledge of subject matter is organized into schemas and it is these schemas that determine how new information is dealt with. For example, consider schemas that deal with common objects such as trees. No two trees have identical elements but each tree seen can be instantly incorporated into a tree schema. As a consequence, if asked to describe a particular tree from memory, a person’s description will be heavily influenced by a tree schema rather than entirely by the particular tree elements (leaves, branches, colour etc.) actually seen. Tree schemas allow people to deal effortlessly with the potentially infinite variety of objects called trees.


In a similar manner, there are schemas for dealing with problems. These schemas allow the classification of problems into categories according to how they will be dealt with, i.e., according to solution mode (e.g., see Chi, Glaser & Rees, 1982). Most people who have completed algebra courses, if faced with an algebraic problem such as (a + b)/c = d, solve for a, will be able to solve it immediately irrespective of the actual pro-numerals used. If, for example, the expression on the right side of the equation is long and complex, a schema will indicate that complexity at this location is irrelevant and the problem will be no more difficult to solve than with a simple expression. Schemas for this category of algebra problems allow the infinite variety of expressions incorporated in the category to be dealt with.


Schemas can be used to explain most of the learned, intellectual skills that people exhibit. People are able to read the infinite variety of the printed and handwritten versions of text that they can potentially encounter because they have acquired schemas for each letter, many words and probably even many word combinations. Learning to solve problems occurs by learning problem categories defined by the moves required for solution. These schemas permit people to readily solve problems that otherwise they would have immense difficulty solving if they had to rely solely on constructing a solution based on first principles.


Interest in schema theory has waxed and waned over many years with alternative terminology frequently being employed. Miller’s (1956) concept of a chunk could be used as readily as the term schema, as could Schank and Abelson’s (1977) scripts. In more recent times, Koedinger and Anderson (1990) provided an excellent formal analysis of schema-based problem solving. While their model is restricted to geometry problem solving, there seems little reason to suppose that the basic principles they employ should not be genera&able to a wide range of problem solving materials. Low and Over (1990) provide techniques for assessing schema acquisition for word problems that may be generalize to other types of material. In summary, knowledge and intellectual skill based on knowledge is heavily dependent on schema acquisition. Schemas provide the basic unit of knowledge and through their operation can explain a substantial proportion of our learning-mediated intellectual performance.

ERROR PATTERN ANALYSIS

Error Pattern Analysis is an assessment approach that allows you to determine whether students are making consistent mistakes when performing basic computations. By pinpointing the pattern of and individual student's errors, you can then directly teach the correct procedure for solving the problem. While there are common errors that students with learning problems make, students may demonstrate error patterns that are individual specific.


Error Pattern Analysis provides you an effective and efficient method for pinpointing specific problems students are having with computation. By determining that your student is consistently using an inaccurate procedure for solving computation problems, you can then provide specific instruction and monitoring to assist the student to use an effective procedure for solving specific types of computations. Additionally, you may discover through error pattern analysis that a student does not have an accurate working knowledge of a major mathematical concept. In other words, specific types of error patterns can cue you that a student not only uses an ineffective procedure to compute a problem, but that the student also does not accurately understand an important math concept. More oftentimes than not, error pattern analysis is much more than a diagnostic tool for determining a student's procedural effectiveness; often, it provides you a window for determining that a student lacks basic conceptual understanding. Students who have difficulty learning mathematics, typically lack important conceptual knowledge. This situation is due to various student learning
characteristics as well as instructional factors including: a student's slow rate of processing information relative to instructional pace, lack of sufficient opportunities to respond (practice), lack of specific feedback regarding misunderstanding or non-understanding, anxiety about mathematics, and visual as well as auditory processing difficulties.


The following steps describe the process for completing error pattern analysis, (Howell, Fox, & Morehead, 1993):

1. Collect a sufficient number of student computation samples for each type of problem you are interested in (at least 3 to 5 samples for each type of problem).

2. As the student works the problems, encourage him/her to talk aloud about what they are doing. Do not cue the student in any way.
3. Record all student responses, both written and verbal.

4. Review the responses and look for patterns among common problem types.

5. Also look for examples of "exceptions" to an apparent pattern (accurate "exceptions" may indicate that the student has partial understanding of the procedure or of a basic concept).

6. List in simple words the patterns you discover, then write beside each pattern why you think it is causing the student problems (e.g. if a student fails to regroup double digit addition problems, it may indicate that he does not understand the concept of place value).

7. Interview the student by asking her to explain how she solved the problem. Hearing what a student was thinking can help you confirm suspected error patterns and how they are impacting your student's success.


Common types of error patterns for the basic operations include number fact errors, "slips," & "bugs" (Ginsburg, 1987). Number fact errors occur because a student has not mastered the basic facts. "Slips" refer to mistakes made due to lapse in memory or due to impulsivity. These errors usually do not indicate misunderstanding. They usually occur because of particular learning characteristics possessed by a student (e.g. memory deficits, impulsivity, visual/motor integration problems). "Bugs" are most serious because they indicate a student is systematically using an inaccurate/inefficient procedure or strategy. Typically, this type of error pattern indicates non-understanding of an important math concept.

Common Error Patterns (Mercer & Mercer, 1998)

• The sums of the ones and tens are each recorded without regrouping. This error pattern reflects a lack of regard for or non-understanding of place value.

• All digits are added together. This error pattern reflects an inaccurate procedure (algorithm) and a lack of regard for place value.

• Digits are added from left to right. When the sum of a column is greater than 10, the "unit," or "one's" place-holder is carried to the column on the right. This error pattern reflects an inaccurate procedure (algorithm) and a lack of regard for place value. 

• The smaller number is always subtracted from the larger number without regard to placement of the number (whether it is the upper number, the minuend, or lower number, the subtrahend, is irrelevant). This error pattern reflects an inaccurate procedure (algorithm). Additionally, the student may be using this procedure to avoid regrouping. This may indicate either misunderstanding of the importance of place value or a visual/motor deficit that makes the regrouping process difficult.

• Regrouping is used when it is not needed.

• When regrouping is needed more than once, the correct value is not subtracted from the column borrowed from in the second regrouping (e.g. when the upper number in the tens an hundreds column are "borrowed from," the values of those upper numbers are not changed.)

• The regrouped number is added to the multiplicand in the tens column prior to performing the multiplication operation. 

• The zero in the quotient is omitted.

Tuesday, 3 September 2013

Overcoming Working Memory limitations

Working memory problems are identified as a cause of learning difficulty. Thus, it is important to minimize the working memory demands in the classroom activities if we are to help students in their learning. There are several effective strategies to reduce working memory demands and achieve success in learning situations. Cognitive load theory recognizes three methods that can help students to accommodate the limitations of working memory (Eggan & Kauchak, 2007):
• Chunking
• Automaticity
• Dual processing


Chunking is the process of grouping into units: it could be a single number, a letter, or many pieces of information. Miller (1956) found that human beings can remember no more than seven plus or minus two items at a time, and the amount of the information in short term memory could be increased by chunking. The nature of the items plays a major role in the capability to recall. It is much easier, for instance, to recall 7 letters that make a word than to recall 7 unrelated letters. Another example of chunks can be found when we want to recall 14 digits for telephone number (00441413306565). It is very difficult to recall this number at once. However, we can recall this number easily if we remember that 0044 the international access , 141 the local access , and 330 the access for local University. After the chunking process, only four digits 6565 are needed to be recalled.


Automaticity refers to the ability to perform a task with low level of awareness without occupying the mind (Healy et.al, 1993; Schneider & Shiffrin, 1977). It is usually the consequence of learning, repetition, and practice. Ordinary activities such as walking, speaking, typing at keyboard, and driving a car are examples of automaticity. Stanovich (1990) stated that automaticity is a fundamental requirement for developing higher-level cognitive skills. It is possible after adequately practicing an activity, to concentrate the memory on other activities while preceding an automaticised activity. For example, people can hold a call or speak while driving a car. This ability can be applied in mathematics learning, where basic operations such as addition and multiplication must be automatic in the learner’s mind, to permit the space of working memory to be occupied for solving a task. In case these basic operations are not mastered automatically, the learner will think about the product of 7 × 9 , for example, instead of solving the problem and not enough working memory space will be left to solve it (Eggan & Kauchak, 2007). 


Dual processing attributes to benefiting from the feature of multi-components of working memory suggested by Baddeley (1992). Working memory consists of visual and auditory working memory, and while each is limited in capacity, they can work individually. This feature can be capitalized-on by presenting information in both visual and verbal forms (Mayer, 1997, 1998; Sweller et.al, 1998). Whereas Gathercole et.al, (2006) indicated three ways that the teacher should take into consideration for managing and reducing the working memory demands: Ensure that the child can remember the task: Memorize activity instructions is an important step to achieve success in learning. Thus, the instructions should be as brief as possible for making them easy to remember. Gathercole et.al, (2006) advise to break the instructions down into smaller constituents where possible, which will have also the benefit of abbreviating a complicated task. The most successful way to enhance memory for the task instructions is the frequent repetition of them. Use external memory aids: The utility of external memory aids will facilitate the complex activities, which decree considerable processing as well as storage loads. Children, at the basic level, fall back on their fingers to aid them to get the answers for addition processes. Older children and adult do more complicated tasks and the
use of the calculators in maths classes helps to reduce the processing loads on the working memory especially for students with low working memory capacity. For example, the volume of conic formula . This complicated formula requires excessive processing and storage demands for retrieving the decimal multiplying operation if it is solved by paper and pencil. Reduce processing loads: Complex learning situations may cause a combination of excessive storage and processing demands, which generate a disruption of the student’s performance. To avoid this disruption, the processing load of the task should be cut down (Gathercole et.al, 2006). Bull & Espy (2006) declared that cognitive limitations do lead to difficulties in learning basic arithmetic and mathematic skills, and to help students in their learning, these cognitive limitations need to be determined.


Furthermore, teachers should avoid any question that may confuse the learner’s mind. Some teachers desire to introduce a task in the tests to confuse the learner rather than to assess his understanding of any topic. The square root of 16 is a good example of such task that cause confusion for the learner. When the students are asked ‘what is the square root of 16, they answer 4. However, in multiple choice questions, the majority choose 8 as a root of 16 even when they understand the meaning of the square root. This incorrect choice is a consequence of the confusion that occurs in learner’s mind from the similarity of adding two 8s. Adding is confused with squaring.

Limitations of Working Memory

There is a general awareness that the capacity of working memory is limited and has to be shared for holding and operating processes. Overloading occurs when the learner tries to hold too many pieces of incoming data. Thus, if we attempt to do too much at once we simply overload. Barber (1988) argued if the information we are concerned with reaches the upper limits of our working space, an overloading in the capacity of working memory could occur, and a loss in productivity may arise. Studies (Johnstone and Wham, 1982; Johnstone and Letton, 1991) show that overloading of working memory appears when the learner is incapable of discriminating between the “noise” (irrelevant information or that which the teacher considers unimportant) and “signal” (relevant information the teacher thinks are important). As we can see in figure 3-13, it is necessary during an experiment to recall: theory, names of apparatus, and recognise material, recall skills, new written instructions, new skills, new verbal instructions.


The study of Johnstone (1980) showed that a sudden drop in the learner’s performance was apparent when any task load exceeded the upper limit of the learner’s working memory capacity. Johnstone (1999) noted that overload happens very often during lectures. Because all students' working space is devoted to writing notes based on the lecturerspoken words, little space is left for elaborating them and thus understanding them. This is very similar to what Jonhstone and Wham (1982) found with laboratory work . In the science field, Johnstone (1984) indicated there are three aspects which can hinder student learning: the nature of the science; the methods of teaching a science; and the methods by which students learn. Johnstone and El-Banna (1989) examined the relationship between working memory and problem solving success in chemistry. They showed that, if the number of the items of information the students are supposed to hold in
the mind at the same time, in order to solve the problem exceeds their working memory capacity, their performance will drop dramatically.


In the mathematics field, Ashcraft (1994) declared that three aspects of mental calculation could overload working memory; the retention of temporary information, the length of time of that retention, and the number of operations involved in the calculation. The Christou study (2001), which investigated the difficulties of solving algebra story problems, showed that the phenomenon of overloading of working memory capacity could be responsible for students’ difficulties in algebra story problems representation. He found a sharp drop in performance when a task demanded more working memory space than a student possessed.


Student ability to develop techniques to cope with information overload depends heavily on the conceptual framework already established in his long-term memory. It is known that working memory is not expandable but it can be used more efficiently. Miller (1965) put forward the idea of “chunking” which is the process of organising information and uses strategies to bring several items together into meaningful units. Gathercole et.al, (2006) indicated the next step after detecting a student with poor working memory ability is to determine the learning activities that will place heavy memory demands. Some types of learning activities demand storing a considerable amount of material that may be arbitrary in structure (such as a series of numbers or the precise wording of a fairly lengthy sentence), and other activities involve the storing of material while being engaged in another activity (such as spelling or reading a new word or making an arithmetic calculation).


Overall, working memory capacity is limited, so overloading can easily occur. When working memory is overloaded, the processing of information cannot take place unless this information can be effectively chunked. However, as Johnstone and El-Naeme (1991) stated “there is an added limitation which leads to inefficient use of this working/ holding/ thinking space. This can occur at the selection stage in which the sensory input is filtered, to separate out or processing, that which is deemed to be relevant, important or interesting.” Overloading of working memory can lead to memory failures. Gathercole et.al, (2006) illustrated that memory failures occur when forgetting the instructions, failing to cope with Concurrent processing and storage demands, losing track in complex tasks, and episodic forgetting.




Working memory - the workplace of cognition

In recent years, the notion of short-term memory has been developed into the concept of working memory. Working memory is a system providing temporary storage and manipulation of the information that is supposed to be essential for creating important links between perception and controlled action. Reisberg (1997: 143) states: “Working memory, it seems, deserves its name: it is indeed the workplace of cognition. But if working memory is to serve this function, then it must be capable of storing and working with all the diverse content that we can contemplate and attend – pictures and words and smells and abstract ideas, to name just a few.”


Johnstone (1984) distinguishes between short-term memory and working memory and introduces an explanation for the distinction between them. For remembering a set of numbers, like phone number, this process occurs in our short-term memory and no processing is taking place to recall it in the same order within a matter of seconds. However, to memorize them backwards, a working process must take place and the short term memory is now called working memory. Essentially, short-term memory and working memory are the same space but the use defines the name.


Johnstone (1984) introduced a definition of working memory from the educational viewpoint as “that part of the brain where we hold information, work upon it, organize it, and shape it, before storing it in long-term memory for further use.” The working memory space is very limited in terms of both its capacity (amount of information it can hold) and its duration (length of time it can hold information). Furthermore, working memory space depends on the age of the individual, and as Miller (1956) showed from memory experiments, the average capacity is about seven plus or minus two ( 7 ± 2 ) separate chunks. Chunking is the process of grouping into units which could be a single number, a letter, or many pieces of information, and the nature of the items plays a major role in the capability to recall.


Baddeley and Hitch (1974) suggested one of the most influential models of working memory. Based on their findings, they conceived that working memory as a multi-component system; the central executive is aided by two peripheral and independent systems – the phonological loop and the visuo-spatial working memory – that temporary store verbal and visuo-spatial information. This theoretical framework illustrates a development of earlier models of short-term storage (such as the model of Atkinson & Shiffrin, 1968).


It is arguable that the central executive system is the most important of the three components of the working memory model because it controls the allocation of resources between the phonological loop and visuo-spatial working memory. The central executive is considered to be multi-functional and complex, and there is a considerable debate about the precise nature of its function (Bull & Espy, 2006). Miyake et.al, (2001) proposed that visuo-spatial working memory has a closer relationship with the central executive than the phonological loop, and visuo-spatial working memory can store more information as a whole. Although the central executive is the most important, it is the least understood component of the working memory (Baddeley, 2006).


The phonological loop is a slave system that specialises in processing the language-based information. Baddeley (1999) proposed that the phonological loop can be divided into two subcomponents: Passive phonological store is able to hold verbal information, for example before the memory trace vanishes or is refreshed by the articulatory control process (the second component), which is an active phonological rehearsal mechanism. Bull & Espy (2006) clarified the characteristic of the phonological loop as follows "Information held in the phonological store is subject to decay, unless it can be refreshed by sub-vocal rehearsal, a process akin to repeating under one's breath the information one is trying to retain. Sub-vocal rehearsal, then, can be disrupted by secondary tasks that also use the verbal resources of the PL". Visually presented material (e.g. written material) can be also converted into an articulatory code by the articulatory control process and then it will be transferred to the phonological store (Baddeley, 1997).


Many researchers have used this phonological loop characteristic to study its processes, using the secondary or dual-task methodology (Lee & Kang, 2002; Furst & Hitch, 2000; Logie et.al, 1994). There are basic phenomena associated with the phonological loop as follows (Logie, 1995; Baddeley, 2006): The phonological similarity effect is the clearest phenomena associated with the phonological loop, and it refers to the fact that recall of a series of words or letters is more confusing when these words or the letters sound alike. For example, sequential recalling for a series such as “Mat, Cat, Fat, Rat, Hat, Chat” is more difficult than a sequence such as “Bus, Clock, Spoon, Fish, Grate, Man”. This phenomenon results from the confusion of the similarity of the verbal items that comprised in the phonological to one another (Baddeley, 1966a; Conrad, 1964).


Irrelevant Speech refers to the disruption that occurs from presenting irrelevant speech, while the recalling process is held. Salame & Baddeley (1982) discussed the disruptive effect of irrelevant speech. This kind of speech involves the conveying of ideas not relevant to the task in hand. The irrelevant speech accesses directly the phonological store, thereby disturbing its contents. Word length effect is a phenomenon where recalling sequences of long words such as “University, Aluminium, Hippopotamus, Mississippi, Refrigerator” is less well done than short words sequences such as “Pen, Book, Chair, Greece, Nail” (Baddeley et.al,1975). The interpretation of the word length effect is that long words take a longer time to say or rehearse, allowing a greater degree of trace decay, thus will be less well retained (Baddeley et.al, 1975; Logie, 1995; Baddeley, 2006).


Articulatory Suppression: is a dramatical collapse in retaining a verbal sequence when subjects are concurrently required to repeat aloud an irrelevant speech sound such as “the, the, the” or “hiya, hiya, hiya” (Levy, 1971, 1975; Murray, 1965, 1968). The Visuo-spatial working memory is a second slave system of working memory which parallels the phonological loop for processing visual and spatial information. Evidence from a number of sources now proposes that the visuo-spatial working memory may involve two subcomponents: one for maintaining visual information and the other for spatial information (Pickering et.al, 1998. Pickering et.al, 2001). Hue and Ericsson (1988) found visual similarity effects in instant recall of unfamiliar Chinese characters. Frick (1988) argued that images in visual-spatial memory are unparsed and uncategorised. He reported when visual confusion errors occur in retention of letters there appears to be independent degradation of parts of the letter, so the letter ‘P’ might be recalled consequence of the similarity effect as an ‘R’. However, the attention that has been paid to study this slave system is much less than the phonological loop. 


Baddeley (2006) justified this because of the absence of a rich and standardized set of stimuli such as those provided by the languages, visual information is much more difficult to quantify. He continued , "It seems likely that the visuo-spatial system will play a crucial role in the acquisition of our visual and spatial knowledge of the world: What color is a banana? How does a bicycle work? How do you play a DVD? How can I find my way around my hometown? Whereas we have many tests of language at the levels of phonology, individual word meaning, and text comprehension, we appear to lack well-developed measures of visuo-spatial world knowledge." However, Baddeley draws attention to the compensating properties for studying the visuo-spatial working memory and the important of vision and visual attention.