Wednesday, 28 August 2013

Self-regulated learning

Self-regulated learning is a process that assists students in managing their thoughts, behaviors, and emotions in order to successfully navigate their learning experiences. This process occurs when a student’s purposeful actions and processes are directed towards the acquisition of information or skills. Generally, models of SRL are separated into phases. One popular cyclical model (see Figure 1) discusses three distinct phases: Forethought and planning, performance monitoring, and reflections on performance (Pintrich & Zusho, 2002; Zimmerman, 2000).


 During the forethought and planning phase, students analyze the learning task and set specific goals toward completing that task. When students learn unfamiliar topics, however, they may not know the best ways to approach the task or what goals might be the most appropriate. Teachers and/or more experienced peers often can instruct students on effective approaches in cases like these.


Next, in the performance monitoring phase, students employ strategies to make progress on the learning task and monitor the effectiveness of those strategies as well as their motivation for continuing progress toward the goals of the task. Unfortunately, when strategies are new, students sometimes revert to using more familiar—and perhaps ineffective—strategies. For example, students may lapse into using the familiar strategy of flash cards to study new vocabulary words because it might seem easier than the new, effective strategy presented by the teacher. Whereas taking the time necessary to practice and learn the new strategy could lead to meaningful learning, students’ use of their fall-back strategy will likely leave them with a considerably less effective means to their learning. Close teacher monitoring and specific feedback can help students learn to use new strategies with fluency, especially if students face frustration.


In the final reflection on performance phase, students evaluate their performance on the learning task with respect to the effectiveness of the strategies that they chose. During this stage, students also must manage their emotions about the outcomes of the learning experience. These self-reflections then influence students future planning and goals, initiating the cycle to begin again.



Self-regulated learners’ proactive qualities and self-motivating abilities help to distinguish them from their peers. Research shows that self-regulated students are more engaged in their learning. These learners commonly seat themselves toward the front of the classroom (Labuhn, Zimmerman, & Hasselhorn, 2010), voluntarily offer answers to questions (Elstad & Turmo, 2010), and seek out additional resources when needed to master content (Clarebout, Horz, & Schnotz, 2010). Most importantly, self-regulated learners also manipulate their learning environments to meet their needs (Kolovelonis, Goudas, & Dermitzaki, 2011). For example, researchers have found that self-regulated learners are more likely to seek out advice (Clarebout et al., 2010) and information (De Bruin et al., 2011) and pursue positive learning climates (Labuhn et al., 2010), than their peers who display less self-regulation in the classroom. Due to their resourcefulness and engagement, it is not then surprising that findings from recent studies suggest that self-regulated learners also perform better on academic tests and measures of student performance and achievement (Schunk & Zimmerman, 2007; Zimmerman, 2008). In a study of high school students, Labuhn et al. (2010) found that learners who were taught SRL skills through monitoring and imitation were more likely to elicit higher levels of academic self-efficacy (i.e., confidence) and perform higher on measures of academic achievement compared to students who did not receive SRL instruction. It seems as though SRL can make the difference between academic success and failure for many students (Graham & Harris, 2000; Kistner, Rakoczy, & Otto, 2010).

Approaches to algebra

In the last two decades, the growing interest in algebra learning and teaching has instigated an international discussion on what we believe (school) algebra to be and what we believe it should be. Contemporary researchers have identified kernal characteristics of algebraic reasoning and algebraic language – such as generalizing, formalizing and symbolizing – which are related to different aspects of algebra (Kieran, 1989, 1990, 1992; Filloy & Rojano, 1989; Sfard, 1991, 1995; Sfard & Linchevski, 1994; Herscovics, 1989; Herscovics & Linchevski, 1994; Linchevski & Herscovics, 1996; Bednarz, Kieran & Lee, 1996; Kaput, 1998). A few months ago the Twelfth ICMI study ‘The Future of the Teaching and Learning of Algebra’ raised issues like ‘why algebra?’, ‘approaches to algebra’, ‘language aspects of algebra’, ‘early algebra education’, ‘technological environments’, and more. Meanwhile it has become clear that there is no agreement on what algebra is or what it should be; each classification has its strong and weak points. Therefore, instead of trying to establish what algebra is, one might consider algebra in terms of its roles in different areas of application instead.


Bednarz et al. (1996) distinguish four principal trends in current research and curriculum development of school algebra: generalizing, problem solving, modeling and functions. These different roles of algebra can be associated with the various ways in which the authors conceive algebra, and which characteristics of algebraic thinking they believe ought to be developed in order to find algebra meaningful. A fifth perspective presented by Bednarz et al. is the historical one, not as an alternative way to introduce algebra at school but as a valuable pedagogical tool for teachers and educational researchers.


The same researchers recognize that the classification is oversimplified and incomplete, and that various approaches have not yet been adequately researched: “The separation into four approaches to ‘beginning algebra’ is artificial; all four components are needed in any algebra program. (...) Some other possible approaches have probably been omitted.” (ibid., p. 325). Still, Bednarz et al. observe that their classification
has helped to structurize their discussion on essential issues of school algebra. roles of letters Some years earlier, Usiskin (1988) proposed a slightly different categorization of perceptions of algebra: as generalized arithmetic, as a study of procedures for solving problems, as a study of relationships among quantities (including modeling and functions) and as a study of structures. In each of these approaches to algebra Usiskin identifies different roles of the letter symbols: pattern generalizer, unknown, argument or parameter, or arbitrary object respectively. One might argue that this list is not complete; other meanings of the concept of variable that are mentioned regularly are those of placeholder (a symbol in an arithmetical open sentence such as 3 + • = 5), letter not evaluated (like and e) and label (letter to abbreviate an object, or a unit of measurement). A variable that varies (as argument or parameter) is considered to be of a higher level of formality than the variable as generalized number or unknown, which is again more formal than the placeholder; at the top end we find the arbitrary symbol. This subtle variation of meanings of letters has been identified .


A number of other characterizations of algebra can be found in the literature. For instance, the National Council of Teachers of Mathematics (1997) identifies four themes for school algebra: functions and relations, modeling, structure, and language and representation. Kaput (1998) has listed five forms of algebraic reasoning: generalizing and formalizing, algebra as syntactically-guided manipulation, algebra as the study of structures, algebra as the study of functions, relations and joint variation, and algebra as a modeling language.
In the present study we do not take an explicit position on what is the best classification of algebra. It is only relevant that we recognize which aspects of algebra are relevant for the proposed learning program. The algebraic activities that we have developed can be described as ‘advanced arithmetic’, with a large component of problem solving and studying relations . We have no clear preference for one classification or the other; it is only for the practical reason of having a framework that we have made a choice. 


If algebra is construed as a product of generalizing activities, its main purpose is to grasp generality, for instance by expressing the properties of numbers. The Oxford Dictionary exemplifies this perspective by defining algebra as the ‘study of the properties of numbers using general numbers’. Algebraic skills are directed at translating and generalizing given relationships among numbers. This approach to algebra stands a better chance if the learner’s intuitive base for the structure of algebra is already nourished in arithmetical activities. For example, Booth (1984) has suggested that if a student is to perceive an expression like a + b as an object in algebra, he or she must be able to view the sum 5 + 8 as an object in arithmetic, rather than as a procedure leading to the outcome 13.


Algebra - major stumbling block

Algebra is known to be a major stumbling block in school mathematics, both in the past and at present. Historical studies on the developments of algebra education in the twentieth century show that the algebra studied in secondary school has not changed much over the years. Unintentionally algebra has functioned as a means of selecting the more capable learners – the ‘happy few’ who understand and enjoy the powers of algebra – from the rest, who experience and remember it as an elusive interplay of letters and numbers. Problems with algebra can be ascribed to external factors like the teaching approach and a poor image, but also to intrinsic difficulties of the topic.

Researchers have reported that grown-ups often have a negative image of school algebra, and many students can make no sense of it. There is a plausible explanation for this. Traditional school algebra is primarily a very rigid, abstract branch of mathematics, having few interfaces with the real world. It is often presented to students as a pre-determined and fixed mathematical topic with strict rules, leaving no room for own input. Traditional instruction begins with the syntactic rules of algebra, presenting students with a given symbolic language which they do not relate to. Students are expected to master the skills of symbolic manipulation, before learning about the purpose and the use of algebra. In other words, the mathematical context is taken as the starting-point, while the applications of algebra (like problem solving or generalizing relations) come in second place. Students are given little opportunity to find out the powers and possibilities of algebra for themselves. One can imagine that an average or below-average learner finds little satisfaction in practicing mathematics without a purpose or a meaning. Another characteristic of the traditional apLearning and teaching of school algebra proach is the rapid formalization of algebraic syntax. School algebra has always had a highly structural character, where algebraic expressions are conceived as objects rather than computations or procedures to be carried out. The procedural (or operational) aspects of algebra, which are more closely related to the arithmetical background that early algebra learners have, are usually cast aside soon after the introduction. This procedural-operational duality of algebra .


Even though we all have an immediate idea what students learn when they learn school algebra, it is not an easy task to give a cast-iron definition. In an attempt to capture ‘school algebra’ in one sentence, we might suggest it is the mathematical domain dealing with (general) relationships between quantities on a symbolic level. Still, this description does not do justice to the multiple roles and utilities of algebra. Typical topics of school algebra include simplifying algebraic expressions, the properties of number systems, linear and quadratic equations in one unknown, systems of equations in two unknowns, symbolic representations and graphs of different kinds of functions (linear, quadratic, exponential, logarithmic, trigonometric), and sequences and series. In most of the core activities we find aspects of algebraic thinking (mental processes like reasoning with unknowns, generalizing and formalizing relations between magnitudes and developing the concept ‘variable’) and algebraic symbolizing (symbol manipulation on paper). Generally it is agreed that students must acquire both competencies in order to have full algebraic understanding.


Teaching and Learning a New Algebra With Understanding - 1

To discuss the teaching and learning of algebra with understanding, we must first look at the algebra students too often encounter in their classrooms. The traditional image of algebra, based in more than a century of school algebra, is one of simplifying algebraic expressions, solving equations, learning the rules for manipulating symbols the algebra that almost everyone, it seems, loves to hate. The algebra behind this image fails in virtually all the dimensions of understanding  having taken as a starting point for reform in the classroom. School algebra has traditionally been taught and learned as a set of procedures disconnected both from other mathematical knowledge and from students' real worlds. 


Construction of relationships and application of newly acquired knowledge are not at the heart of traditional algebra: The "applications" used are notoriously artificial (e.g., "age problems" and "coin problems"), and students are neither given the opportunity to reflect on their experiences nor the support to articulate their knowledge to others. Instead, they memorize procedures that they know only as operations on strings of symbols, solve artificial problems that bear no meaning to their lives, and are graded not on understanding of the mathematical concepts and reasoning involved, but on their ability to produce the right symbol string—answers about which they have no reason to reflect and that they found (or as likely guessed) using strategies
they have no need to articulate. Worst of all, their experiences in algebra too often drive them away from mathematics before they have experienced not only their own ability to construct mathematical knowledge and to make it their own, but, more importantly, to understand its importance–and usefulness–to their own lives.


Although algebra has historically served as a gateway to higher mathematics, the gateway has been closed for many students in the United States, who are shunted into academic and career dead ends as a result. And even for those students who manage to pass through the gateway, algebra has been experienced as an unpleasant, even alienating event - mostly about  manipulating symbols that don't stand for anything. On the other hand, algebraic reasoning in its many forms, and the use of algebraic representations such as graphs, tables, spreadsheets and traditional formulas, are among the most powerful intellectual tools that our civilization has developed. Without some form of symbolic algebra, there could be no higher mathematics and no quantitative science, hence no technology and modern life as we know them. 


Our challenge then is to find ways to make the power of algebra (indeed, all mathematics) available to all students—to find ways of teaching that create classroom environments that allow students to learn with understanding. The broad outlines of the needed changes follow from what we already know about algebra teaching and learning:
· begin early (in part, by building on students’ informal knowledge),
· integrate the learning of algebra with the learning of other subject matter (by extending and applying mathematical knowledge),
· include the several different forms of algebraic thinking (by applying mathematical knowledge),
· build on students' naturally occurring linguistic and cognitive powers (encouraging them at the same time to reflect on what they learn and to articulate what they know), and
· encourage active learning (and the construction of relationships) that puts a premium on sense-making and understanding.


Making these changes, however, will not be easy, especially where the new approaches involve new tools, unprecedented applications, populations of students traditionally not targeted to learn algebra, and K-8 teachers traditionally not educated to teach algebra (neither the old algebra nor some new version). Despite these challenges, this chapter suggests a route to deep, long-term algebra reform that begins not with more new-fangled approaches but with the elementary school teachers and the reform efforts that currently exist. This route involves generalizing and expressing that generality using increasingly formal languages, where the
generalizing begins in arithmetic, in modeling situations, in geometry, and in virtually all the mathematics that can or should appear in the elementary grades. Put bluntly, this route involves infusing algebra throughout the mathematics curriculum from the very beginning of school. Although this article is not designed to show this route to teaching for understanding in greater detail, I have chosen to organize the material around the different forms of algebraic reasoning in order to demonstrate how algebra can infuse and enrich most mathematical activity from the early grades onward. These interrelated forms, form a complex composite.  All forms richly interact conceptually as well as in activity. To understand this algebra is to make a rich web of connections. Together, the forms of reasoning and the classroom examples emphasize where we need to go rather than where we are, or have been. I will discuss them in coming articles.

Potential problems with individualized instruction and remediation

What are the potential problems that can arise with individualized instruction and remediation?
Apart from the practical problems arising from inadequate resources, there can be problems with the methods that are used. In particular, there may be gaps in the selection of arithmetical components for remediation. Indeed, in our present state of knowledge there must be, since we do not yet have a full understanding of the different components of arithmetic; the relationships between them; and the nature and causes of individual differences in them. Although such topics have been studied for many years, our understanding of them still has limitations, due to the number (considerably more than seems to be the case for reading) and complexity of the components; the difficulties and controversies involved in defining successful acquisition of numeracy (Brown, 1999; Baroody, 2003; Cowan, 2003); and the fact that some important methods of studying the issues, such as functional brain imaging, have only recently become available. Nevertheless, there has been sufficient knowledge in the area for quite some time to permit successful work in the area.


Moreover, appropriate individualized instruction depends on appropriate selection of the components of arithmetic to be used in assessment and intervention. This is still an issue for debate and one which requires considerable further research. One of the main potential problems, which was more common in the past than nowadays, is to assume that the components to be addressed must necessarily correspond to specific arithmetical operations: e.g. treating "addition", "subtraction", "multiplication", "division" etc. as separate components. It is, of course quite possible for children to have specific problems with a particular arithmetical operation. Indeed, as we have seen, it is possible for a particular arithmetical operation to be selectively impaired in adult patients following brain damage. Nevertheless, it is an over-simplification to assume that these operations are likely to be the primary components of arithmetical processing. Current classifications tend to place greater emphasis on the type of cognitive process; e.g. the broad distinctions between factual knowledge ("knowing that"), procedural knowledge ("knowing how"), conceptual knowledge ("knowing what it all means") and in some theories utilizational knowledge ("knowing when to apply it") (see, for example, Greeno, Riley and Gelman, 1984). A potential danger of over-emphasizing the different operations as separate components is that it may encourage children, and perhaps adults, to ignore the relationships between the different operations.

Another potential problem - again commoner in the past though still a danger nowadays - is looking at children's difficulties only in terms of procedural errors. It is, of course, important to investigate the strategies that individual children use in arithmetic, including those faulty arithmetical procedures that lead to errors. Nonetheless, diagnosing the incorrect strategies is not always the final step. There may be a conceptual reason why the incorrect strategy is acquired and maintained or there may be unperceived conceptual strengths, which need to be noted and built on (Tilton, 1947; Ginsburg, 1977).


Such diagnostic work is vital. Children do indeed frequently acquire incorrect strategies, which can become entrenched, especially if the child is given too much of the wrong sort of arithmetical practice. Nonetheless, diagnosing the incorrect strategies is not always the final step. There may be a conceptual reason why the incorrect strategy is acquired and maintained. In the case of the faulty subtraction strategies described above, their acquisition could result from an assumption that larger numbers cannot be subtracted from smaller numbers, combined with an inadequate understanding of place value which makes it difficult for children to understand the nature and purpose of borrowing. As Tilton (1947, p. 85) goes on to remark, "Many of the errors made by these... children seemed to be due to an insufficient understanding of the meaning of numbers. It seems as if these children had been asked to learn the rules for the manipulation of numbers in addition, subtraction and multiplication without having learned the meaning of the symbols that they have been asked to manipulate".


More generally, interventions need to take into account the fact that arithmetical ability is made up of many components. Ginsburg (1972) pointed out that "children's knowledge of mathematics is extraordinarily complex and often much different from what we had supposed it to be... In the case of every child we have interviewed or observed, there have emerged startling contradictions, unsuspected strengths or weaknesses, and fascinating complexities". Of course, no intervention programme can take into account all possible components, but they are likely to be most effective if not restricted to one or two components, and if they allow for different children having different types of difficulty, which may not be restricted to procedural
difficulties.


Arithmetical difficulties in relation to verbal and spatial ability

Reasoning, including arithmetical reasoning, can be carried out in many ways. Two broad categories that are often discussed with regard to individual differences are verbal and spatial reasoning. Information can be represented, manipulated and analysed in words; it can also be represented, manipulated and analysed in terms of visual-spatial imagery. A number of researchers have investigated the issue of whether arithmetical skills are particularly associated with verbal or spatial reasoning and/or with discrepancies between the two. The factor analytic studies used to construct some commonly used IQ scales have consistently placed the Arithmetic subtest (one which emphasizes word problem solving) within the Verbal scale. However it has sometimes been suggested that spatial difficulties are particularly associated with difficulties in arithmetical reasoning.

 Rourke (1983, 1993) proposed that verbal weaknesses lead to memory difficulties and that nonverbal weaknesses lead to logical difficulties. He proposed two basically different groups of children with arithmetical learning difficulties. Children in the first group have difficulties in retrieval of number facts and in working memory, but have a reasonably good understanding of number concepts. They have higher nonverbal than verbal IQs and often have difficulties with reading as well as mathematics. Children in the second group do not have memory problems but do have conceptual problems; they have higher verbal than nonverbal IQs; are less likely to have reading or language difficulties, but more likely to have spatial and social difficulties associated with right hemisphere deficits. A few studies by Rourke and others (e.g. Robinson, Menchetti and Torgesen, 2002) have supported the view that children with both reading and mathematical deficits tend to have more memory difficulties but fewer conceptual difficulties than those with just mathematical deficits. However, there has been no consistent support for the view that 'left hemisphere'-type verbal deficits are associated with procedural and factual memory difficulties in arithmetic, while 'right-hemisphere'-type nonverbal deficits are associated with conceptual difficulties inarithmetic. Shalev, Manor, Amir, Weirtman and Gross-Tsur (1997) found no differences in the types of mathematical difficulty demonstrated by dyscalculic children with higher verbal versus higher non-verbal IQ.

Jordan and Hanich (2000) studied 76 American second-grade children. They were divided into four achievement groups: 20 children with normal achievement in reading and mathematics; 10 children with difficulties in both reading and mathematics (MD-RD), 36 children with difficulties in reading only (RD) and 10 children with difficulties in mathematics only (MD). They were given tests of four areas of mathematical thinking: number facts, story problems, place value and written calculation. Children with MD/RD performed worse than NA children on all aspects of mathematics; those with MD performed worse than NA children only on story problems.


Hanich, Jordan, Kaplan and Dick (2001) similarly divided 210 second-graders into four achievement groups: children with normal achievement in reading and mathematics; children with difficulties in both reading and mathematics (MD-RD), children with difficulties in reading only (RD) and those with difficulties in mathematics only (MD). Both MD groups performed worse than the other groups in most areas of arithmetic. The MD-only group outperformed the MD-RD group in both exact mental calculation and problem solving. The two MD groups performed similarly on written calculation, place value understanding, and approximate arithmetic.


Geary, Hoard and Hamson (1999) studied 90 first-grade children in the average IQ range. They included 35 children with normal achievement in reading and mathematics (N); 15 children with mathematical difficulties (MD; as shown by scores below the 30th percentile on the Mathematical Reasoning subtest of the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test); 15 children with reading difficulties (RD; as shown by scores below the 30th percentile on the Word Attack subtest of the Woodcock Johnson Psycho-Educational Battery; and 25 children with both mathematical and reading difficulties (MD/RD). Both MD groups showed problems in fact
retrieval and in using counting strategies correctly in arithmetic. Children who had difficulties with both mathematics and reading tended to show problems in understanding counting principles and detecting counting errors; those with only MD or RD did not. However, about half of the MD children made double-counting errors. The MD/RD children, and those MD children who made double-counting errors, had lower backward digit spans than the other children.


So, the studies by Jordan and her colleagues and by Geary et al (1999) suggest that children with combined mathematical and reading disabilities tend to perform badly on more aspects of mathematics than children who only have mathematical difficulties; but do not support the type
of dichotomy suggested by Rourke. 

Thus, while signs of verbal or spatial weaknesses should serve as a warning signal that a child may experience mathematical difficulties, they cannot be used as definite predictors of either the existence or type of mathematical difficulty that a child may have. There is still less evidence that, within the general population, verbal and nonverbal ability are associated with consistently different forms of strengths and weaknesses within arithmetic. (This is not to say that there might not be such patterns within the broader domain of mathematics; e.g. geometry is likely to be more specifically associated with spatial ability than is arithmetic). Dowker (1995, 1998) looked at WISC IQ scores, calculation and derived fact strategy use in 213 children between the ages of 6 and 9. Both Verbal and Performance I.Q. predicted performance on tasks of both arithmetical calculation and derived fact strategy use. Verbal I.Q. was a stronger predictor than Performance I.Q. of both types of arithmetical task. Children who showed a strong discrepancy between verbal and nonverbal I.Q. in either direction tended to do well at tasks that involve the use of derived fact strategies; such discrepancies did not predict calculation performance.


The problem of mathematical difficulties

Children's numeracy difficulties can take several forms. Some children have difficulties with many academic subjects, of which arithmetic is merely one; some have specific delays in arithmetic, which will eventually be resolved; and some have persisting, specific problems with arithmetic. The causes for such difficulties are also varied, though they tend to overlap: they include individual characteristics (e.g. unusual patterns of brain development); inadequate or inappropriate teaching; and lack of preschool home experience with mathematical activities and language. The type and extent of intervention needed to address arithmetical difficulties will depend in part on the nature and causes of these difficulties. For example, intervention is more necessary for children with persisting arithmetical difficulties than for those with temporary delays.

There have been several studies of arithmetical difficulties and their characteristics. As will be seen in the section on the history of individualized interventions, research has been carried out on arithmetical errors and faulty procedures since at least the 1920s. Many people experience difficulties with mathematics. For example, Bynner and Parsons (1997) gave some Basic Skills Agency literacy and numeracy tests to a sample of 37-year-olds from the National Child Development Study cohort (which had included all individuals born in Britain in a single week in 1958). The numeracy tests included such tasks as working out
change, calculating area, using charts and bus and train timetables, and working out percentages in practical contexts. According to the standards laid down by the Basic Skills Agency, nearly one-quarter of the cohort had 'very low' numeracy skills that would make everyday tasks difficult to complete successfully. This proportion was about four times as great as that classed as having very low literacy skills. Most of the adults with numeracy difficulties had already been experiencing difficulties with school mathematics at the age of 7.
The reasons for these people's mathematical difficulties are undoubtedly various. Some would have had insufficient or inappropriate instruction in mathematics. Some would have had learning difficulties affecting many subjects. There is no doubt, however, that some individuals experience learning difficulties that are relatively specific to mathematics. Several studies have investigated the prevalence of learning difficulties in mathematics.

Gross-Tsur, Manor and Shalev (1996) assessed the incidence of dyscalculia in a cohort of 3029 Israeli 11- to- 12-year-olds. The 600 children who scored in the lowest 20% on a standardized city-wide arithmetic test were selected for further testing. 555 were located and given an individualized arithmetic test battery previously constructed and standardized by the authors. This included reading, writing and comparing numbers; comparing quantities; simple calculations; and more complex (multi-digit) calculations. 188 children or 6.2% of the total were classified as having dyscalculia, using the criterion of a score equal or below the mean for children two years younger. 143 of these children were located and receivedparental consent for further testing. This included the WISC-R IQ test, and reading and spelling tests standardized on 70 age-matched typically developing children. 3 children were excluded from the 'dyscalculic' group because they obtained IQ tests below 80. Of the 140 dyscalculic children, 75 were girls and 65 were boys, once again indicating an approximately equal gender distribution. Their IQs ranged from 80 to 129, with a mean of 98.2. They were assessed for symptoms of other learning problems. The researchers diagnosed 17% as dyslexic, and 26% as having symptoms of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. They came from significantly lower socio-economic backgrounds than the children without dyscalculia. 42% had first-degree relatives with specific learning disabilities.

Bzufka, Hein and Neumarker (2000) studied 181 urban and 182 rural German third-grade pupils. They were given standardized school achievement tests of arithmetic and spelling. 12 children in each sample (about 6.6% of the whole population) performed above the 50th percentile in spelling, but below the 25th percentile in mathematics. When the urban and rural children were compared, they showed little difference in incidence of specific spelling or mathematics difficulties, but the urban children [who were on the whole of lower socioeconomic background] were far more likely than the rural children to have difficulty with
both (48.6% versus 3.3%).

Thus, the incidence of mathematical learning difficulties depends widely between studies, depending on the methods and criteria used. For example, they have used different IQ tests; different mathematics tests –which may be emphasizing quite different components; and different cut-off points for establishing deficit in both IQ and mathematics. Moreover, it has been pointed out (Mazzocco and Myers, 2002; Desoete, Roeyers and DeClercq, 2004) that findings about the incidence, nature and outcomes of mathematical difficulties may vary
considerably, depending on whether one uses criteria of discrepancy between mathematical performance and IQ, severity of mathematical weaknesses, or persistence of mathematical weaknesses. Given the marked differences in criteria between studies, it is perhaps inappropriate to focus too much on the exact numbers obtained. The main conclusion one can gain from most studies is that many children have difficulties with mathematics, and a significant number have relatively specific difficulties with mathematics.

Ultimately, the criteria for describing children as having 'mathematical difficulties' must involve not only test scores, but the children's educational and practical functioning in mathematics. Within the present educational system, it may be considered that children have some degree of mathematical difficulty; and that those who have failed to reach the above levels have quite marked mathematical difficulties.